A degree, a job and a salary that falls short
More than 65% of Malaysia's fresh graduates earn less than RM3,000, about US$700, a month, according to the Gaji Cukup Makan Economy report by Future Studies Berhad. Around 70% work in roles classified as semi-skilled or unskilled, often outside their field of study. For many young Malaysians, completing university has brought neither the income nor the kind of work they expected.
Contents
- A degree, a job and a salary that falls short
- University expansion has outpaced skilled job creation
- What underemployment means for a graduate
- Why the economy keeps producing lower paid work
- A degree still pays more, but its advantage has narrowed
- Rent, daily expenses and student debt squeeze the paycheck
- Universities and employers face a mismatch in expectations
- The costs extend beyond individual careers
- What the proposed responses need to address
- Key Points
Computer science graduate Andy Yap describes being told that even RM3,000 was too much to expect as a starting salary. Some engineering graduates report offers just above RM1,000. Their experiences sit within a decade of stagnant graduate pay, during which more than half of new graduates have consistently earned below RM2,000 a month.
Malaysia's problem reaches beyond the size of a first paycheck. Graduates who accept jobs requiring less education can struggle to use their training, gain relevant experience and move into better paid positions. Rent, daily expenses and education debt then compete for a small income, leaving financial independence and savings out of reach.
As of June 16, 2025, the challenge is to connect three parts of the same problem: the rapid expansion of university education, the limited supply of jobs requiring advanced skills, and wages that struggle to meet living costs. Raising starting pay matters, but graduates also need positions in which their qualifications have a practical use.
Future Studies Berhad's findings describe fresh graduates, while other figures cover broader groups of workers with tertiary education. Together, they show pressure at the point of entry into employment and a wider shortage of suitable work for people who have studied beyond secondary school.
A graduate may therefore be employed and still face a difficult start. Having a job answers the immediate need for income; whether that job uses the person's skills and pays enough to live on determines much of what comes next.
University expansion has outpaced skilled job creation
Malaysia's tertiary education enrollment grew from fewer than 50,000 students in 1980 to more than 1.2 million in 2020. Those figures represent an increase of more than 24 times. The expansion gave far more people access to higher education, but the creation of jobs requiring advanced skills did not keep pace.
In 2022, only about 25% of Malaysian jobs were classified as high-skilled, a share that had remained flat for years. In 2023, just 17% of new jobs were in that category. The first figure describes the existing job market; the second describes the jobs being added to it. Both point to limited opportunities for graduates to apply specialized training.
Employers with suitable vacancies can choose from a growing pool of degree holders. Graduates who cannot secure those positions may accept work below their qualifications to avoid unemployment. That helps them earn an income immediately, but often at a lower salary than they hoped to receive after university.
The figures trace how educational growth and employment opportunities have moved at different speeds:
- 1980: Tertiary enrollment stood below 50,000 students.
- 2020: Enrollment exceeded 1.2 million students.
- 2021: The Khazanah Research Institute found that 48.6% of graduates were overqualified for their jobs.
- 2022: About 25% of jobs were classified as high-skilled.
- 2023: Only 17% of new jobs were high-skilled, while nearly 2 million workers with tertiary education were underemployed by late in the year.
What underemployment means for a graduate
The Khazanah Research Institute, known as KRI, found that nearly half of graduates, 48.6%, were overqualified for their jobs in 2021. Only 43.4% were employed in roles matching their education level. Overqualification means that a worker has more education than the job requires.
The Department of Statistics Malaysia recorded nearly 2 million workers with tertiary education in underemployment by late 2023. In this context, underemployment means working in a position that does not require the level of education the worker has completed. A person can work regularly and still have skills that the job rarely uses.
Graduates accepting such positions can face a wage penalty: they receive the pay attached to the job rather than the higher income they might earn in work suited to their qualifications. That choice can be understandable when the alternative is having no income, especially when rent and loan repayments are already due.
A low starting salary can also affect later earnings because subsequent pay growth is often anchored to that initial amount. Graduates who begin on lower wages can remain behind their peers for years, while work outside their field may limit opportunities to build the experience needed for a specialized career.
More than half of graduates in 2021 lacked the security and benefits of permanent employment on full working hours. Temporary work, contracts, work on reduced hours and self employment have become more prevalent. These arrangements can bring income, but they also leave graduates facing uncertainty about continuity of work and access to employment benefits.
Why the economy keeps producing lower paid work
Malaysia remains heavily reliant on industries organized around low costs and large amounts of labor. Services, manufacturing and the gig economy account for a large share of jobs. The concentration of employment in work requiring low or intermediate skills limits the number of positions available for graduates seeking to use advanced training.
Small and medium enterprises, or SMEs, make up more than 97% of Malaysian businesses. Many have limited resources to offer competitive salaries, train employees or provide structured career development. For graduates, that can mean a vacancy is available without a clear route to higher earnings or more demanding responsibilities.
The shortage of suitable jobs therefore has two connected sides. Graduates are entering the labor market in large numbers, while many employers operate businesses that cannot readily support higher pay or work requiring advanced skills. A large supply of applicants competing for a limited number of suitable roles keeps wages under pressure.
Reliance on low cost foreign labor, weak labor market institutions and insufficient enforcement of labor laws compound these difficulties. Together with the concentration of jobs requiring fewer skills, these conditions help keep wage levels low across the workforce, including among graduates.
A degree still pays more, but its advantage has narrowed
Graduates earned 2.7 times as much as holders of the Sijil Pelajaran Malaysia, or SPM secondary school qualification, in 1997. By 2022, that ratio had fallen to 1.7 times. The income advantage associated with a degree remained, but it had become much smaller.
This advantage is often called the graduate wage premium. It is the extra pay associated with higher education compared with a lower qualification. A narrowing premium makes the financial calculation behind university study more difficult, particularly for families with low or middle incomes that borrow to cover education costs.
Former Bank Negara Malaysia governor Muhammad Ibrahim noted that a fresh graduate salary of RM1,300 in 1984 would be equivalent to RM7,000 to RM8,000 today after accounting for inflation. Current starting salaries, however, remain between RM2,000 and RM3,000.
Inflation reduces what money can buy. A salary can rise in ringgit terms while buying no more goods and services, or even fewer, than it did before. Graduate wages have increased slightly in nominal terms, meaning the amount paid, but wages adjusted for inflation have stagnated or declined.
Malaysia's graduates are consequently weighing the cost of years of study against a weaker earnings advantage and rising living expenses. For those carrying education debt, the concern is immediate: repayment begins competing with the costs of establishing a working life.
Rent, daily expenses and student debt squeeze the paycheck
The Employees Provident Fund estimates that a single adult needs at least RM1,930 a month to get by in the Klang Valley. Bank Negara Malaysia puts a living wage at RM2,700. These benchmarks show how little room many starting salaries leave once basic expenses are considered.
Urban centers such as Kuala Lumpur and Penang have seen living costs outpace wage growth. Graduates can find themselves spending nearly everything they earn, cutting back on essentials or relying on family support. Housing arrangements become a financial decision as much as a personal one.
Howard Ng, a graduate aged 23, describes the pressure on a monthly salary of RM3,000. His account focuses on the cost of rent and everyday necessities:
barely enough
A graduate working as a physiotherapist earns RM2,400 and lives with her brother to reduce expenses. Her situation shows how family support can make a limited salary stretch further, while also delaying the independent living that many graduates hoped employment would allow.
Surveys indicate that a substantial portion of graduates spend RM100 to RM300 a month repaying education debt. Some devote more than 40% of their income to those payments. At that level, debt takes up a large part of the paycheck before housing, food and other necessities are covered.
Limited money after bills leaves little space for savings, investment or professional development. Financial strain can also lead to poor financial decisions or reliance on loans charging high interest, adding another expense to a budget that is already tight.
Universities and employers face a mismatch in expectations
Employers report that graduates often lack practical skills, industry exposure and abilities such as communication and teamwork. University courses that have not kept pace with technological changes or workplace requirements can leave students well prepared for examinations but less prepared for the tasks a job demands.
Malaysia's education system places considerable weight on academic achievement. Critical thinking, creativity and adaptability receive less attention, even though employers increasingly value them. These abilities help workers solve unfamiliar problems, explain ideas and respond when a task or technology changes.
Universities and employers therefore have work to do together. Updating curricula, arranging internships and building structured partnerships can connect academic study with practical experience. Students gain opportunities to apply their knowledge, while employers can help identify the skills needed in their workplaces.
Germany's dual education system and Switzerland's vocational training programs provide examples of combining theoretical learning with practical experience. Vocational education and strong partnerships between public bodies and businesses can help people enter employment with knowledge they have already used in a working environment.
Malaysia's low wage baseline and slow creation of jobs requiring advanced skills make its underemployment problem more acute. Better preparation can help graduates compete for suitable work, but the economy also needs more such positions. Training and job creation must advance together for more graduates to benefit.
The costs extend beyond individual careers
Career consultant Sharifah Hani Yasmin warns that prolonged underemployment and limited earnings affect the country as well as the graduates experiencing them. She describes the wider stakes this way:
A generation stuck in a cycle of underemployment, career frustration and stagnant income is not just a graduate issue, it is a national one.
Persistent low pay can weaken confidence in higher education and widen inequality. Graduates with family support may be better able to manage low starting wages, while those who must meet their own expenses and repay loans have less room to wait for a suitable opportunity.
Malaysia also faces the loss of skilled workers to countries offering better pay and career opportunities, particularly neighboring Singapore. As of 2022, nearly 1.9 million Malaysians had migrated overseas, with a substantial proportion classified as skilled or semi-skilled workers. The loss of such workers reduces the talent available to support innovation and economic growth at home.
Employee compensation also accounts for a smaller share of gross domestic product, or GDP, than in developed countries. GDP measures the value of goods and services produced in an economy. A low compensation share means workers receive a smaller portion of those economic gains.
Wage stagnation consequently bears on Malaysia's ambition to become a nation with high incomes. An economy built around knowledge and specialized work needs people who can use their education productively and see a reason to develop their careers within the country.
What the proposed responses need to address
The New Industrial Master Plan 2030 aims to create millions of new jobs. Investment and industrial upgrading in areas such as technology, clean energy and biotechnology could expand opportunities for graduates, but delivery depends on effective implementation and matching those jobs with the skills graduates possess.
The Progressive Wage Policy, or PWP, and targeted wage subsidies offer ways to raise salaries, particularly where urban living costs are high. These measures need flexibility across sectors and links to measurable results, including productivity and further training. Productivity means the amount of useful output generated by work; improving it can help businesses support higher wages.
SMEs need support to invest in training, career development and employee retention. Tax incentives for training, partnerships between public bodies and businesses, and accessible professional development programs can help employers and workers build skills throughout a career.
Universities also need to modernize teaching, expand practical experience and strengthen communication and teamwork skills. Lifelong learning and reskilling can help graduates respond as job requirements change, while structured links with employers can make courses more relevant to work.
Housing allowances, rent controls and support for remote work are among the proposed ways to reduce financial pressure on young workers. Stronger enforcement of labor laws, collective bargaining and regular wage reviews could also give employees greater protection and a stronger voice in pay decisions.
These proposals address different parts of the same problem: the availability of suitable jobs, the capacity of employers to pay more, graduates' preparation for work and the cost of living. The central challenge is to turn educational achievement into employment that uses people's skills and supports a sustainable income.
Key Points
- More than 65% of fresh graduates earn below RM3,000 a month, and more than half have consistently started below RM2,000 over a decade.
- Around 70% of fresh graduates work in semi-skilled or unskilled roles, often outside their field of study.
- Tertiary enrollment rose from fewer than 50,000 students in 1980 to more than 1.2 million in 2020, while jobs requiring advanced skills remained limited.
- KRI found 48.6% of graduates overqualified in 2021; nearly 2 million workers with tertiary education were underemployed by late 2023.
- The earnings ratio between graduates and SPM holders narrowed from 2.7 times in 1997 to 1.7 times in 2022.
- Living expenses and education debt leave many graduates with little money for savings or career development.
- Low pay and unsuitable work risk widening inequality, encouraging migration and weakening Malaysia's economic ambitions.
- Proposed responses combine better education and training, more jobs requiring advanced skills, wage measures, SME support and stronger worker protections.






