Pakistan Minister Avoids Direct Terrorism Answer at SCO Forum in Delhi

10 Min Read
Pakistan Minister Avoids Direct Terrorism Answer at SCO Forum in Delhi

A rare visit meets an unresolved security dispute

Pakistan's climate minister, Musadik Masood Malik, called for dialogue and a joint mechanism to examine evidence on terrorism during his November 20 visit to New Delhi, but did not directly answer questions about networks operating from Pakistani soil. The exchange took place at the first Shanghai Cooperation Organisation Civilisational Dialogue Forum, a gathering focused on cultural ties rather than formal talks between India and Pakistan.

Contents
  1. A rare visit meets an unresolved security dispute
  2. What did Malik say about terrorism?
  3. Why was the forum held, and who was invited?
  4. Can culture create room for dialogue?
  5. What is the backdrop to the dispute over water?
  6. Why did the invitation cause political criticism?
  7. Some leaders welcomed the chance to meet
  8. What happens after the forum?
  9. Key Points

Malik led Pakistan's delegation to the three day event at Purana Qila, a historic fort in the Indian capital. His visit was the first by a Pakistani federal minister to India since Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari attended an SCO meeting in Goa in May 2023. Saad Warraich, chargé d'affaires at Pakistan's High Commission in India, received Malik at the airport.

Asked about terrorism, Malik said the forum should address wider regional issues, including instability in Iran, Central Asia and Afghanistan. He acknowledged that India had also experienced terrorist attacks, while returning to his call for both countries to present evidence.

Malik told reporters that he wanted discussion at the gathering to remain focused on its multilateral purpose. He said regional challenges went beyond disputes between India and Pakistan.

I do not wish to reduce such a significant, wide-ranging dialogue to a purely bilateral context.

The forum ran from November 20 to 22 and brought together representatives of the SCO's 10 member states, as well as invited observers and dialogue partners. India's Ministry of Culture and Ministry of External Affairs hosted the event at Purana Qila.

Advertisement

What did Malik say about terrorism?

When reporters pressed him on why Islamabad had not acted against terrorist networks accused of operating from Pakistan, Malik did not describe any specific action by his government. He instead said that both countries should submit evidence and work through a transparent process.

Malik argued that Pakistan had also suffered heavily from terrorism. He said thousands of Pakistanis had been killed and presented an evidence sharing mechanism as a way to build trust and find solutions.

Both sides must bring forward evidence. Our objective is to establish a transparent mechanism, a proposal we have put forward on several occasions. Such a mechanism would help restore trust and could lead to viable solutions.

At another point, Malik said he did not want to present Pakistan only as a victim and said his country was doing its utmost to address the situation. He did not outline what those efforts involved. Earlier, when asked about cross border terrorism, he deferred an answer, saying he expected more discussion after delivering a statement the following day.

India has repeatedly accused Pakistan of allowing armed groups to use its territory to attack India. Malik's remarks acknowledged the dispute but shifted the focus from the specific allegations to a proposed process for examining evidence. No joint mechanism or agreement to create one was announced at the forum.

Why was the forum held, and who was invited?

India described the event as a multilateral SCO gathering, rather than a special bilateral meeting with Pakistan. External Affairs Ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said invitations had gone to all SCO members, including Pakistan, along with observer states and dialogue partners. The ministry said this followed the group's established practice.

Defence Minister Rajnath Singh announced India's plan to host the dialogue at an SCO Council of Heads of Government meeting in Dushanbe, Tajikistan, on October 20. India became a full member of the SCO in 2017, the same year as Pakistan. The organisation was founded in 2001 by China, Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. Iran joined in 2023.

Pakistan's Foreign Ministry said Malik would take part in thematic sessions and present his country's view of how dialogue among civilisations could contribute to diplomacy. The event's stated aim was to encourage cultural exchange, mutual understanding and contact among people in the SCO region. The programme scheduled four thematic sessions on November 21 and 22, with scholars, academics, subject experts and cultural representatives discussing cultural forms such as music and performing arts; shared traditions in art and architecture; language and literary heritage; and monastic trails and philosophical traditions. No formal conclusions or outcome document were reported.

The main dates around the gathering were:

  • October 20: Rajnath Singh announced the plan for India to host the forum at an SCO meeting in Dushanbe.
  • November 14: Pakistan announced that Malik would attend.
  • November 20: Malik arrived in New Delhi, and the forum opened at Purana Qila.
  • November 21: Malik was expected to deliver a statement at the forum.
  • November 22: The three day gathering was scheduled to end.
Advertisement

Can culture create room for dialogue?

Malik repeatedly made the case that culture could help countries understand one another despite political disputes. He said the value of cultural exchange extended beyond India and Pakistan to the wider region, where countries share histories and links across borders.

Asked how culture might improve relations between India and Pakistan, Malik said understanding different ways of thinking and living was necessary for regional progress.

Unless we understand each other, our way of thinking and manners of living, we won't be able to grow. Through dialogues, we will get each other's perspectives and get to know each other's understanding, and that's how the region will be able to grow.

Malik also described dialogue as an exchange between distinct points of view. In a separate comment, he said, "Singularity only requires a monologue. Dialogue is about diversity." He called the forum a significant chance for countries to discuss shared history, geography and culture.

At the same time, Malik said there were no bilateral matters on the forum's agenda, describing it as a multilateral event. He added that India had raised some multilateral matters. That distinction helps explain why the event could bring Indian and Pakistani officials into the same venue without becoming a formal negotiation on terrorism, water sharing or other disputes.

What is the backdrop to the dispute over water?

Malik's visit drew added attention because of his earlier comments about the Indus waters. In June, he threatened that Pakistan would "cut off those hands" that tried to control its water supply. Congress leaders cited the remark while objecting to his presence in India.

The dispute concerns the Indus Waters Treaty, the 1960 agreement that sets rules for sharing the Indus river system between the two countries. India suspended the treaty in 2025 after the April 22 attack in Pahalgam, Jammu and Kashmir, which killed 26 people. India's External Affairs Ministry said its position on the treaty had not changed.

On May 13, 2025, External Affairs Ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said India would keep the treaty in abeyance until Pakistan "credibly and irrevocably abjures" its support for cross-border terrorism. He linked the position to the Cabinet Committee on Security decision of April 23, saying: "The Indus Waters Treaty was concluded in the spirit of goodwill and friendship as specified in the preamble of the treaty. However, Pakistan has held these principles in abeyance by its promotion of cross-border terrorism for decades. Now, as per the Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS) decision of 23 April, India will keep the Treaty in abeyance until Pakistan credibly and irrevocably abjures its support for cross-border terrorism. Please also note that climate change, demographic shifts and technological changes have created new realities on the ground." Prime Minister Narendra Modi also said: "Terror and talks cannot happen at the same time. Terror and trade cannot happen simultaneously. Water and blood cannot flow together."

India and Pakistan also fought a military conflict from May 7 to 10, 2025, after India launched strikes on what it said were terrorist sites in Pakistan. The exchanges lasted about 87 hours. Diplomatic contact between the neighbours has remained limited, making Malik's visit an unusual encounter even though it took place under the SCO's wider regional framework.

Malik said culture had a key role in improving relations, but the forum did not announce a change in either country's position on the treaty or on terrorism. India did not announce a bilateral meeting with Malik, and Pakistan did not announce an agreement with India during the gathering.

Advertisement

Why did the invitation cause political criticism?

India's Congress party accused the government of inconsistency for welcoming a Pakistani minister while saying that terrorism must end before dialogue can resume. Congress spokesperson Supriya Shrinate said the visit was hurtful to families of those killed in the Pahalgam attack. Party leaders also pointed to Malik's June threat over water.

Congress MP Manish Tewari said Pakistan's participation in SCO events was routine because it was a member, but argued that Islamabad had not changed its conduct on terrorism. Former foreign minister Salman Khurshid said the government's approach to Pakistan was unclear and called for it to explain its policy.

BJP leader Nalin Kohli rejected the charge that India had made a special invitation to Pakistan. He said the invitations went to all SCO members and that there could be no dialogue while terrorism was directed against India. The government's position, as stated by the External Affairs Ministry, was that the invitation formed part of a multilateral event and followed established practice.

The political disagreement is about what the invitation signifies. Congress leaders treated the minister's welcome as inconsistent with the government's stated opposition to talks while terrorism continues. The BJP said attendance at an SCO event does not amount to bilateral dialogue or a change in policy.

Some leaders welcomed the chance to meet

Former Jammu and Kashmir chief minister Farooq Abdullah welcomed Malik's visit and said he hoped India and Pakistan would resume talks. Abdullah dismissed the earlier water threat as rhetoric and urged the two governments to speak about peace.

Peoples Democratic Party legislator Aga Syed Muntazir Mehdi also called for dialogue, saying shared concerns could not be resolved through continued non engagement. National Conference leader Bashir Ahmad, by contrast, accused the BJP of applying a double standard, saying it criticised others for advocating talks but accepted a Pakistani minister's presence at the forum.

Malik said he hoped his visit would not be a one off and that contact between the two countries would continue. He also described Pakistan as a constructive participant in efforts to address instability in the region. These remarks expressed his hopes, rather than announcing a plan for continuing official talks.

What happens after the forum?

Malik was expected to deliver his statement on November 21, while the forum's wider programme continued through November 22. He was also granted permission to travel to Agra to visit the Taj Mahal. A requested visit to Nizamuddin Dargah in Delhi was declined on security grounds.

Whether the visit leads to further official contact was not settled at the forum. The two governments had not announced a bilateral meeting, and Malik's call for an evidence sharing process was not accompanied by an agreed plan or timetable. For now, the clearest result was that officials from the two countries attended the same multilateral event while maintaining their opposing positions on terrorism and the Indus Waters Treaty.

The gathering therefore showed both the opportunity and the limit of cultural diplomacy. It created a setting for officials to discuss shared heritage and regional concerns, but the central security dispute remained unresolved.

Key Points

  • Pakistan minister Musadik Masood Malik attended the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi from November 20 to 22.
  • Malik called for both India and Pakistan to present evidence on terrorism, but did not directly address allegations about networks operating from Pakistani soil.
  • India said it invited all SCO members as part of the multilateral event and that its position on the Indus Waters Treaty was unchanged.
  • Congress criticised the invitation, while BJP leader Nalin Kohli said it did not amount to bilateral dialogue.
  • The forum did not announce a new India-Pakistan agreement or a plan for formal talks.
Share This Article

You May also Like