A proposal to remove some pregnancy limits divides doctors
Nepal's debate over changing its Safe Motherhood and Reproductive Health Rights Act, 2075 centers on a consequential question: when a pregnancy threatens a woman's health, involves a child subjected to rape, or has severe fetal complications, should the law retain its current limit of 28 weeks?
Contents
- A proposal to remove some pregnancy limits divides doctors
- What the existing law allows
- How Nepal reached this debate
- Why doctors disagree about later pregnancies
- Children subjected to rape need a workable route to care
- What happens if a baby is born alive?
- Safeguards must fit hospitals' capabilities
- Access, prevention and enforcement are connected
- Key Points
The proposed amendment would allow termination at any stage in specified circumstances, while retaining the general right to abortion with the pregnant woman's consent up to 12 weeks. Its most contested provisions concern later pregnancies, including those resulting from rape or incest involving girls younger than 18.
Doctors disagree over how those exceptions should work. Some warn that unclear wording could expose babies capable of surviving outside the womb to harm. Others say the existing limit can prevent necessary treatment and leave both patients and clinicians facing serious risks.
The government's documented consultation began with a ministry consultation notice dated 9 Asar 2082 BS, seeking opinions on a draft amendment. That notice provides an official reference point for the proposal. A verified parliamentary filing date, final legislative text and timetable for a decision have not been established.
The immediate stakes extend beyond a number of weeks. The Nepal Society of Obstetricians and Gynecologists has raised questions about responsibility for babies born alive during treatment, criminal liability when complications occur, registration of abortion providers and the rules governing transfers to better equipped hospitals.
Those questions connect access to abortion with the practical realities of maternity care: what a doctor can legally do, what a hospital can safely provide and who must care for a newborn when a child who became pregnant cannot assume that responsibility.
What the existing law allows
The 2018 Safe Motherhood and Reproductive Health Rights Act provides abortion with the pregnant woman's consent up to 12 weeks. It also permits abortion up to 28 weeks under specified conditions, including pregnancy resulting from rape or incest.
Other grounds for the longer limit include a licensed doctor's opinion that continuing the pregnancy could endanger the woman's life, worsen her physical or mental health, or result in the birth of a child with a disability. The law also addresses HIV or another incurable disease of a similar nature, severe fetal defects and conditions affecting survival after birth.
The amendment debate concerns removing the time limit for particular exceptions. Lawyer Sabin Shrestha describes the proposal as addressing three broad groups: threats to the pregnant woman's life, serious fetal conditions including death in the womb, and pregnancy following rape or incest involving a minor younger than 18.
The proposal is also described as covering serious risks to physical or mental health, certain genetic conditions and pregnancy following rape or incest involving a woman with a disability. Precise definitions matter because those grounds cover different medical and personal circumstances.
Shrestha argues that the general limit should remain. His support for exceptions rests partly on cases in which legal obstacles have left very young girls, including an 11-year-old, having to give birth.
How Nepal reached this debate
Nepal's current discussion follows more than two decades of changes to abortion law and services. The country legalized abortion in March 2002 through the 11th Amendment to the Civil Code, after a period in which seeking or helping to obtain an abortion could lead to imprisonment.
- March 2002: Nepal legalized abortion through changes to the Civil Code.
- December 25, 2003: Legal abortion services began.
- 2018: The Safe Motherhood and Reproductive Health Rights Act established the framework of 12 weeks generally and 28 weeks in specified circumstances.
- 9 Asar 2082 BS: The health ministry published its notice inviting consultation on a draft amendment.
Legal access expanded, but access to safe services remained uneven. Research estimated 323,100 abortions in Nepal in 2014, with 42% classified as legal and 19% followed by treatment for complications. Those historical figures help explain why the debate also concerns access to regulated care, rather than gestational limits alone.
Why doctors disagree about later pregnancies
Obstetrician Dr. Jagdishwar Gautam opposes allowing abortion without a gestational limit when a fetus could survive outside the womb. He argues that treatment after that point should be understood as delivery and that clinicians have duties toward a baby born alive.
Gautam described his experience caring for very premature babies in a public video message:
In developed countries, babies after 22 weeks survive, and even here, babies after 26 weeks are surviving. I have saved hundreds of babies at 26, 27, 28 weeks. Therefore, this is delivery.
Dr. Ganesh Dangal, a former president of the professional society, also favors stronger limits and clearer distinctions between abortion and medically necessary delivery. He has called for explicit rules and opinions from two or more doctors in exceptional cases.
Viability means the possibility of surviving outside the uterus. It depends on the stage of pregnancy, the baby's condition and the care available after birth. A hospital with intensive care for newborns can offer support that a small facility cannot. Survival at a particular week is therefore a clinical assessment rather than a universal guarantee.
Dr. Padmaraj Pant, the society's president, stresses another danger: a legal ceiling can obstruct treatment when a woman's life is at risk or the fetus has a severe congenital condition. He argues that changing the law could give patients and providers a safer legal setting in which to manage those cases.
The disagreement is partly about terminology, but its consequences are practical. The law must tell clinicians how to end a dangerous pregnancy, how to care for a baby born alive and how to make decisions when the fetus has a condition incompatible with survival after birth.
Children subjected to rape need a workable route to care
Girls younger than 18 who become pregnant through rape or incest are central to the proposed exception. Fear, psychological distress, social pressure and legal difficulties can delay their access to treatment until a pregnancy is advanced.
The professional society supports flexibility that takes account of a minor's physical and mental vulnerability. Its submission also highlights what can happen when a pregnancy is ended at 24 or 34 weeks: a baby may be born alive, creating an immediate need for medical care and decisions about guardianship.
A child who has survived sexual violence may be unable to take responsibility for a newborn. The society wants the law to specify who assumes that responsibility and how the baby's care will be managed. This connects the abortion amendment to child protection and hospital responsibilities, not simply permission to perform a procedure.
What happens if a baby is born alive?
The society has raised particular concern about proposed Section 16(c), described as treating the birth of a live baby during an abortion followed by death as forced abortion. It wants clearer protection for clinicians when a death follows natural complications or an accidental event during treatment.
Doctors point to emergencies such as eclampsia, a dangerous pregnancy condition involving seizures. In such circumstances, ending the pregnancy may be necessary to protect the woman's life, while the baby may also need urgent treatment.
The society's request brings two duties into the same discussion: providing care for a newborn and assessing a clinician's conduct fairly. It seeks wording that distinguishes complications arising during necessary treatment from actions that should attract criminal punishment.
That clarity also matters to patients. If doctors fear prosecution when an emergency has a poor outcome, decisions about treatment or transfer can become harder at precisely the moment when time is critical.
Safeguards must fit hospitals' capabilities
Obstetrician Dr. Kirtipal Subedi has called for clear procedures and effective oversight to prevent misuse, including sex selection and pressure on doctors. He has proposed specialist review and documentary evidence for exceptional cases.
Subedi described the safeguards he favors:
Strict legal provisions and effective regulatory mechanisms are necessary to prevent the risk of misuse. Keeping in mind international practices and Nepal's limited health infrastructure, a clear protocol should be established with the opinion of at least two specialists, police documents, and medical evidence.
Requirements for multiple specialists or police documents would shape access as well as oversight. A workable procedure would need to explain how urgent treatment proceeds and how patients in places with few specialists obtain a decision.
The society has separately questioned the proposed registration wording in Section 18(1). It wants flexibility in the act, with detailed service requirements set out in regulations. Another proposed change would require delivery services across health institutions to be provided by skilled health workers or trained midwives.
Proposed Section 25(c)(1), concerning harm linked to failure to refer a patient, has also drawn objections. The society wants clear criteria for when a facility should treat someone and when it should arrange transfer. For hospitals with limited staff or equipment, that distinction affects everyday decisions about patient safety.
Access, prevention and enforcement are connected
Historical research found that about half of pregnancies in Nepal were unintended. Alongside the 2014 estimate that fewer than half of abortions were legal, that finding points to needs extending from contraception and timely advice to accessible treatment.
Nirdesh Vaidya, an associate professor of public health, has called for sex education and public health programs reaching schools and adolescents, together with concrete measures to reduce teenage pregnancy. He also supports clear rules for providers and stronger monitoring.
Shrestha has highlighted enforcement of the existing ban on abortion based on fetal sex. He says the absence of filed cases despite strict penalties points to weak implementation, and has urged the Family Welfare Division to monitor registered facilities and doctors more closely.
Ministry spokesperson Dr. Samir Kumar Adhikari has said the proposal draws on studies and previous experience, with operational details to follow:
The bill has been presented based on all studies and experiences. The procedure will cover all aspects later.
The central policy choice is how much protection and detail should appear in the law itself, and how much should be left to later procedures. Doctors seeking changes want the rules on exceptional treatment, newborn care, referral and criminal responsibility to be clear enough to use when a patient arrives in an emergency.
Key Points
- Nepal's existing framework permits abortion up to 12 weeks generally and up to 28 weeks in specified circumstances.
- The proposed amendment would remove gestational limits for certain exceptional cases, including some involving minors subjected to rape or incest.
- The health ministry published a draft consultation notice dated 9 Asar 2082 BS.
- Doctors disagree over later terminations, while seeking clearer rules on viability, emergency treatment and babies born alive.
- The professional society also wants clarity on provider registration, referral duties and criminal liability for complications.
- Access to timely care, protection of children and enforcement against misuse remain central to the debate.






