Air India Flight 171: Fuel Switches and Cockpit Exchange at Centre of Crash Inquiry

11 Min Read
Air India crash report answers one question – and raises many more | CNN

Two fuel switches at the centre of a fatal flight

Air India Flight 171 climbed to just 625 feet before both engine fuel controls moved to the cut-off position, according to the preliminary investigation. The Boeing 787 Dreamliner crashed into a crowded neighbourhood less than a minute after taking off from Ahmedabad on a clear June morning, bound for Mumbai. All 260 people aboard and several people on the ground were killed.

Contents
  1. Two fuel switches at the centre of a fatal flight
  2. How the engines lost power
  3. What the cockpit exchange reveals
  4. How the fuel controls are protected
  5. The 2018 advisory and possible equipment faults
  6. Emergency power and the landing gear
  7. The crew and the case for cockpit video
  8. Why earlier crashes remain relevant
  9. What investigators are examining next
  10. Key Points

The aircraft was 12 years old. Its engines lost power after their fuel supply was stopped, and an attempt to restart them came too late to recover the flight. Inside the cockpit, one pilot asked the other why he had moved the fuel switches. The other replied that he had not.

As of July 13, 2025, investigators were still trying to explain how both controls reached the cut-off position and identify the speakers in that brief exchange. The co-pilot was flying the aircraft, while the captain was monitoring the flight. The recording described in the preliminary findings did not identify which pilot asked the question or which denied moving the switches.

The inquiry brings together the aircraft's recorded behaviour, the pilots' words, the condition of the fuel controls and the operation of electronic systems. For the families of those killed, the preliminary findings have brought frustration rather than a clear explanation. They continue to seek answers about why a routine departure ended almost immediately in disaster.

How the engines lost power

The preliminary report describes a rapid sequence: both fuel-control switches moved to cut-off, both engines lost their fuel supply, and the switches were then quickly returned to their normal position. Restoring the controls triggered the engines' automatic relight systems, which attempt to restart combustion and bring the engines back into operation.

One engine was regaining thrust as the aircraft descended. The other had relit but had not yet recovered power. That difference matters because an engine can begin burning fuel again before it produces enough thrust to help keep an aircraft in the air. Flight 171 was already losing altitude rapidly when those recovery attempts began.

Advertisement

The sequence described in the investigation is:

  • In December 2018, the US Federal Aviation Administration issued an advisory about the locking feature on certain Boeing fuel-control switches.
  • On a clear June morning, Flight 171 departed Ahmedabad for Mumbai and climbed to 625 feet.
  • Both fuel-control switches moved to cut-off, interrupting fuel to both engines.
  • The switches were quickly returned to their normal position, starting automatic attempts to relight the engines.
  • Less than a minute after takeoff, the aircraft crashed into a crowded neighbourhood.
  • By July 13, 2025, the investigation was continuing, with the cause still undetermined.

The aircraft's low altitude left little room for recovery. The recorded sequence explains how the loss of fuel was followed by the loss of engine power and a rapid descent. Investigators still need to determine what caused the switches to change position.

What the cockpit exchange reveals

The cockpit voice recorder, or CVR, captured one pilot asking why the other had moved the fuel switches to cut-off. The response was a denial. No further discussion about the switches was described in the recording released through the preliminary findings.

Peter Goelz, a former managing director of the US National Transportation Safety Board, questioned how much could be understood from the brief exchange and said more of the recording was needed:

The finding is very disturbing—that a pilot has shut off the fuel switch within seconds of flying. There's likely much more on the cockpit voice recorder than what's been shared. A lone remark like 'why did you cut off the switches' isn't enough.

Investigators are working to identify the voices. That process typically involves asking people familiar with the pilots to listen to the recording. Connecting each voice to the captain or co-pilot would help reconstruct who noticed the loss of fuel, who responded and how the crew handled the emergency.

The captain's monitoring role and the co-pilot's flying role describe their duties at the time. The unresolved voice identification remains a central part of understanding their conversation. Authorities are also working toward a full transcript and a review of communications from the aircraft's pushback from the gate to the crash.

How the fuel controls are protected

Fuel-control switches regulate the supply of fuel to the engines. Moving a switch to cut-off stops that supply. These controls are normally set to cut-off after landing, when the crew shuts down the engines.

The switches are designed with locking mechanisms and guard brackets to prevent accidental activation. A pilot normally has to pull a switch up before moving it to cut-off. Those protections make an accidental movement highly unlikely, especially when both switches are involved.

Advertisement

Shawn Pruchnicki, a former airline accident investigator and aviation expert at Ohio State University, described the question investigators would face if a pilot had operated the controls:

If one of the pilots was responsible for shutting down the switches, intentionally or not, it does beg the question: why? Was it intentional, or the result of confusion? That seems unlikely, as the pilots reported nothing unusual.

The cockpit recording contained no discussion of confusion or an emergency before the incident. That absence, together with the switches' protective design, has made the sudden interruption of fuel particularly difficult to explain.

Investigators must examine the condition and operation of the controls as well as the crew's actions. A switch's normal design and the condition of a particular switch are both relevant when reconstructing how it moved during a flight.

The 2018 advisory and possible equipment faults

The US Federal Aviation Administration issued a Special Airworthiness Information Bulletin in December 2018 after some Boeing 737 fuel-control switches were found to have been installed with their locking feature disengaged. The same switch design is used in the Boeing 787-8, including the aircraft involved in this crash.

The bulletin was advisory. The FAA had not classified the issue as an unsafe condition requiring a mandatory Airworthiness Directive. Air India therefore did not carry out the recommended inspections. An advisory recommends action, while a mandatory directive requires operators to address a specified safety condition.

Pruchnicki also raised the possibility that a switch fault could interrupt fuel without the expected operation of its protective mechanism:

Could the switch just flip itself to off and shut down the engine? If that's the case, it's a really serious issue.

Capt Kishore Chinta, a former investigator with India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau, questioned whether the switches could have been triggered electronically through the aircraft's electronic control unit, rather than through physical movement. An electronic control unit manages aircraft or engine functions through electronic commands.

As of July 13, no evidence of fuel contamination or mechanical failure had emerged. Samples from the refuelling tanks were satisfactory, and no advisories had been issued for the Boeing 787 or its GE GEnx-1B engines in connection with the findings described. The investigation continued to examine possible electronic faults and problems involving the design of the fuel controls.

The 2018 bulletin gives investigators a specific maintenance issue to examine: whether the locking feature was working as intended. The electronic possibility raised by Chinta concerns a different part of the inquiry, the relationship between control inputs and the aircraft's response.

Advertisement

Emergency power and the landing gear

The aircraft's Ram Air Turbine, usually called the RAT, deployed during the emergency. This small propeller extends from beneath the Boeing 787 and uses the airflow around the aircraft to provide limited electrical and hydraulic power when both engines lose power.

Electrical power keeps essential equipment operating, while hydraulic power helps operate aircraft systems through pressurised fluid. The RAT provides an emergency supply for those needs; engine thrust is still needed to sustain powered flight. Its deployment was a sign of a major systems failure.

The landing gear was found in the down position. The preliminary account interpreted that finding as indicating that the pilots had no time to retract it after takeoff. Gear retraction usually completes by around 400 feet of altitude, below the 625 feet reached by Flight 171.

A Boeing 787 pilot, who was not named, described how the sudden loss of both engines could concentrate a crew's attention on controlling the descent:

When both engines fail and the aircraft starts going down, the reaction goes beyond just being startled—you go numb. In that moment, landing gear isn't your focus. Your mind is on one thing: the flight path. Where can I put this aircraft down safely? And in this case, there simply wasn't enough altitude to work with.

The emergency turbine and the landing gear give investigators further information about the aircraft's final moments. Alongside the engine recordings, they help describe what systems were operating and what tasks the crew faced during the short descent.

The crew and the case for cockpit video

Both pilots and the crew had passed breathalyser tests and were cleared as fit to fly. They had arrived in Ahmedabad the previous day and had adequate rest. There was no indication of fatigue, impairment or unusual stress.

The inquiry is examining human factors, meaning how people perceive a situation, make decisions and act under pressure. In this case, the recorded exchange and the lack of any earlier discussion of an emergency are central to reconstructing what the pilots understood as engine power disappeared.

Investigators are calling for cockpit video recorders, a measure recommended by the NTSB. A camera providing a view over the pilots' shoulders could show whose hand was on a fuel-control switch at a critical moment. Audio captures speech and sounds; video could also record physical actions.

Advertisement

Cockpit video remains controversial because of privacy concerns. Flight 171 has brought that debate back into focus because investigators are trying to connect a recorded change in engine operation with an action or fault that the audio alone leaves unexplained.

The crash has also renewed discussion about protections on critical controls, the accuracy of voice identification and the monitoring of electronic systems. Each issue has a practical connection to the inquiry: preventing unintended control movements, identifying the crew's responses and understanding how the aircraft processed commands.

Why earlier crashes remain relevant

Air France Flight 447, which crashed in 2009, and the disappearance of Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 in 2014 illustrate the difficulty of reconstructing a flight when essential evidence is incomplete or difficult to recover.

Investigators studying Air France 447 needed years of analysis and the recovery of flight recorders from the ocean floor to determine that pilot confusion and instrument failure led to the crash. The recorders helped explain the relationship between what the aircraft was doing and how its crew responded.

Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 remains unsolved, with only partial wreckage recovered. The missing aircraft illustrates how limited physical evidence can leave the central events of a flight unresolved.

Those disasters have driven improvements in flight data recording, pilot training and aircraft design. Flight 171 presents its own evidence problem: investigators have information about the fuel controls and a brief cockpit exchange, while the reason for the controls' movement is still being examined.

What investigators are examining next

Authorities are working to produce a full cockpit voice transcript with the speakers identified and to review communications across the flight's entire sequence, beginning with pushback. They are also examining electronic systems, maintenance records and possible design flaws in the fuel-control switches.

International specialists from Boeing, General Electric, Air India, Indian regulators and agencies from the United States and United Kingdom are participating. The work brings together aircraft design, engine operation, maintenance and accident investigation.

Advertisement

No date for the final findings was given. The next steps described are investigative tasks rather than a scheduled public release: identifying the voices, reviewing the complete communications record and checking the aircraft's systems and maintenance history.

The findings may lead to changes in aviation safety standards worldwide, including the treatment of critical controls or the evidence recorded inside cockpits. For now, the immediate task is to explain why both engines lost their fuel supply seconds after departure.

Families of the victims continue to seek a definitive explanation. The final investigation is expected to address the question left at the centre of the preliminary findings: what caused the two fuel controls to reach cut-off while Flight 171 was climbing away from Ahmedabad.

Key Points

  • Air India Flight 171 crashed less than a minute after departing Ahmedabad for Mumbai, killing all 260 people aboard and several on the ground.
  • The Boeing 787 reached 625 feet before both fuel-control switches moved to cut-off and the engines lost power.
  • The switches were returned to their normal position, but the engines had not recovered enough power before the crash.
  • One pilot questioned the movement of the switches; the other denied moving them. Investigators were still identifying the voices.
  • A December 2018 FAA advisory concerned the locking feature on switches of the same design. Air India had not performed the recommended inspections.
  • The inquiry is examining human actions, mechanical and electronic possibilities, maintenance records and aircraft design.
  • As of July 13, 2025, the cause remained undetermined, and no date for final findings had been given.
Share This Article

You May also Like