A Crushed Hand and a Month Without Medical Care
Silwanus Tangkotta, an Indonesian fisherman working on a Taiwanese boat in the Pacific, suffered crushed fingers when a heavy wave slammed a rolling metal door onto his hand. The captain refused to return to port. For more than a month, Tangkotta treated the injury himself, without medical care and in excruciating pain.
Contents
- A Crushed Hand and a Month Without Medical Care
- What Workers Face on Fishing Vessels
- Why a Job Can Begin With Debt
- Two Systems of Labor Protection
- Why Internet Access Has Become a Labor Issue
- What Taiwan Has Promised to Change
- Years of Complaints and Pressure
- How the Catch Reaches Overseas Consumers
- A Wider Fishing Industry Problem
- Indonesia Seeks Better Protection Abroad
- What Is at Stake for Taiwan
- Key Points
His experience captures the dangers facing migrant workers in Taiwan's fishing industry: an injury far from land, a captain who controls whether help is available, and a worker with few ways to challenge that decision. Other fishermen have faced withheld wages, violence, excessive working hours and restrictions on leaving their vessels.
Taiwan operates the world's second-largest distant-water fishing fleet, sending boats far from home to supply seafood markets from the United States to Europe. The industry is among the world's largest and most profitable. Much of its work depends on migrants from Indonesia, the Philippines and Vietnam.
Taiwan has pledged more than NT$2 billion, about US$68.5 million, to improve conditions. Measures include higher minimum pay, limits on time at sea and expanded inspections. Labor organisations say the central problem remains: many people working on these boats lack the legal protections and practical access to help available to other workers.
As of July 13, 2025, the debate reaches beyond individual vessels. It concerns recruitment agencies that put workers into debt, government departments with different responsibilities, seafood companies buying the catch and countries trying to protect their citizens abroad.
What Workers Face on Fishing Vessels
The U.S. Department of Labor has repeatedly identified fish from Taiwanese vessels as goods produced with forced labor. In 2023, the U.S. government again listed the catch, citing deceptive recruitment, withheld wages, physical violence and extreme working hours.
An account by Greenpeace USA described that as the third appearance of Taiwan's distant-water fleet on the list since 2020. The repeated listings point to continuing concerns despite government promises of improvement.
Government reports and nongovernmental organisations have documented a range of indicators of forced labor:
- Hunger and dehydration.
- Degrading and unhygienic living conditions.
- Physical and verbal abuse.
- Restrictions on leaving vessels.
- Withheld wages and illegal deductions.
- Deceptive recruitment and high fees that lead to debt bondage.
- Confiscation of identity documents.
- Working days that sometimes reach 20 hours.
Debt bondage means that a worker's debt becomes a means of control. A fisherman who owes money for recruitment may feel unable to leave an abusive job because doing so would leave the debt unpaid and his family without income.
Isolation makes these pressures harder to escape. A worker on a remote vessel cannot readily visit a government office, find another employer or obtain medical treatment. Weak oversight and gaps in labor protections increase the power of captains, employers and recruitment agents.
Why a Job Can Begin With Debt
Many migrant fishermen pay recruitment agencies thousands of dollars for the promise of work. The borrowing can begin before they board a boat, leaving them dependent on future wages to repay what they owe.
Once at sea, workers may have their passports taken away. Wages may be withheld or reduced through arbitrary deductions. Losing pay while still owing recruitment fees can deepen a worker's dependence on the same employment arrangement that is causing the harm.
The brokerage system ties workers to particular employers and charges high fees. Labor organisations have criticised it for enabling exploitation and debt bondage, and have called for its abolition. Taiwan's government has so far refused to abolish the system.
The threat of dismissal or deportation also discourages complaints. For a fisherman supporting relatives at home, losing a job can mean financial ruin for the household. Reporting an abusive captain therefore carries a personal cost even before any complaint is investigated.
Taiwan's Control Yuan, its top government watchdog, identified more than 1,500 complaints from migrant fishermen between 2017 and 2019, with some agencies receiving more than 100 each. The Control Yuan findings put numbers to a problem that inspections and enforcement have struggled to match.
Two Systems of Labor Protection
Taiwan's rules separate coastal fishing workers from those recruited for distant-water vessels. Coastal fishermen fall under the Ministry of Labor, while those on distant-water boats are regulated by the Fisheries Agency.
The distant-water group makes up the majority of migrant fishers and lacks residency documentation. Most migrant fishermen are excluded from protections under Taiwan's Labor Standards Act, leaving them without guaranteed overtime pay, health insurance or effective channels for reporting abuse.
The Environmental Justice Foundation and other organisations have called for Taiwan to ratify the International Labour Organization's Work in Fishing Convention 188 and apply the Labor Standards Act to all fishers, wherever they work. Their demand is for a worker's protection to follow the person onto the boat.
Allison Lee of the Yilan Migrant Fishers Union criticised the government's priorities, saying officials were concentrating on removal from the U.S. forced labor list instead of the conditions behind the listing:
The government is more concerned with its international image than with the lives and rights of the workers who power its fishing industry.
The division of responsibility matters when a worker seeks help. Campaigners want the Ministry of Labor, rather than the Fisheries Agency, to oversee labor affairs for all fishermen, giving the workforce a common framework for employment protection.
Why Internet Access Has Become a Labor Issue
Many fishing vessels provide no internet access, leaving crew members unable to contact their families or seek assistance while at sea. For workers already far from shore, losing communication removes another route to support.
The Wi-Fi Now for Fishers' Rights campaign has criticised the Taiwan Tuna Association for opposing Wi-Fi on vessels on the grounds that isolation increases productivity. Campaigners argue that workers need a secure way to report abuse as it happens, rather than waiting until a vessel reaches port.
Achmad Mudzakir, chairman of the Indonesian Seafarers Gathering Forum, described communication as part of workers' basic rights:
Fishers should have the right to access their pay, voice concerns, and maintain contact with their families.
Jennifer Rosenbaum, executive director of Global Labor Justice–International Labor Rights Forum, has called for mandatory secure Wi-Fi. She says it would allow fishermen to report abuses in real time and maintain their well-being through contact with others.
For a worker facing withheld pay, violence or injury, an internet connection provides a possible route to a union, family member or authority. Without it, the people able to offer help may remain unaware of what is happening aboard the vessel.
What Taiwan Has Promised to Change
Taiwan's reform package commits more than NT$2 billion, about US$68.5 million, to improving conditions for migrant fishermen. It follows international pressure and prominent cases of abuse.
The minimum monthly salary for foreign crew has risen from US$450 to US$550. That is an increase of US$100, or about 22 percent. The government has also limited time at sea to a maximum of 10 months.
Officials have promised to increase the inspection rate for longline fishing boats from less than 10 percent to 100 percent. Other measures include installing CCTV cameras aboard vessels and prosecuting abusive captains and officers.
Premier Su Tseng-chang presented the treatment of foreign crew as a responsibility toward people seeking a livelihood:
It is the right thing to properly look after these foreign crew members who come from disadvantaged backgrounds and seek a living at sea.
Labor unions and activists say the measures leave deeper problems unresolved. A higher wage has limited value when pay is withheld, while cameras and inspections depend on effective investigation and enforcement. Wage theft, overwork and gaps in legal protection remain widespread concerns.
The Da Wang case illustrates the severity of the abuse that has reached prosecutors. An Indonesian crew member died after being beaten and was stored in a freezer. Prosecutions involving abusive captains and officers have been rare exceptions rather than a routine response.
Years of Complaints and Pressure
The calls for reform stretch across several years. Complaints recorded by Taiwan's watchdog preceded repeated U.S. forced labor listings and the continuing debate over whether government measures reach workers at sea.
- 2017 to 2019: More than 1,500 complaints were filed by migrant fishermen, according to the Control Yuan.
- 2020: The period began in which Taiwan's distant-water fleet would appear three times on the U.S. forced labor list by 2023.
- 2023: The U.S. government again listed fish from Taiwanese vessels, citing abuses including deceptive recruitment, withheld wages and violence.
- July 13, 2025: Higher minimum pay and other reform measures remained under scrutiny from unions and rights organisations.
The Human Rights for Migrant Fishers coalition has called for a broader overhaul. Its proposals connect recruitment, legal coverage, inspections and complaint systems, rather than treating abuse as a problem confined to individual captains.
- Ratify international labor conventions.
- Apply labor laws to all fishers.
- Provide proper labor inspections and training for authorities.
- Create accessible complaint channels for fishermen at sea.
- Develop a clear action plan with regular review by nongovernmental organisations.
- Reform recruitment rules to prevent exploitation.
Campaigners also want legal amendments defining all Taiwanese distant-water fishing vessels as extensions of Taiwanese territory, so national laws apply wherever they operate. The proposed changes would connect the treatment of workers aboard a vessel more directly to responsibilities at home.
No timetable was given for adopting these broader legal and recruitment changes. Their status matters to workers whose immediate options still depend on employers, brokers and access to help while offshore.
How the Catch Reaches Overseas Consumers
Taiwan's seafood industry is deeply connected to international supply chains. The United States imports about 80 percent of its seafood, and Taiwan is a major supplier. Fish caught far out in the Pacific can eventually reach supermarket shelves and dinner tables far from the conditions under which it was caught.
Bumble Bee Foods, owned by Taiwanese tuna trader FCF, is among the major brands linked to fish caught with forced labor. Lawsuits against companies have alleged that they benefit from abusive practices in their supply chains.
Sari Heidenreich of Greenpeace USA urged seafood businesses to take responsibility for the workers behind their products:
American consumers are at risk of consuming seafood tainted by modern slavery. Companies and retailers must scrutinize their supply chains and take responsibility for the human rights of workers.
A Greenpeace scorecard found that only one of 16 major U.S. retailers received a passing grade for human rights in its tuna supply chain. The result points to a problem extending beyond vessels to the companies choosing, buying and selling their catch.
Many companies rely on certifications from outside organisations. Activists argue that these checks are insufficient to guarantee ethical practices. Their demand is for companies to examine the treatment of workers throughout the chain of businesses supplying their seafood.
A Wider Fishing Industry Problem
The abuse affecting migrant fishermen in Taiwan is part of a wider international problem. The United Nations estimates that one in five fish is caught through illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing, often shortened to IUU fishing.
The term covers fishing that breaks applicable rules, goes unreported to the relevant authorities or takes place outside effective regulation. It concerns how fishing activity is controlled and recorded, while forced labor concerns how people doing the work are treated.
About 128,000 workers worldwide are trapped in forced labor on remote fishing vessels. Child labor and forced labor have been documented in fish and seafood production in at least 20 countries.
The U.S. Department of Labor and international organisations are pressing for stronger enforcement, guidance for marine authorities, and the use of trade agreements and sanctions to hold governments and companies accountable. Those efforts connect conditions aboard fishing vessels with the rules governing access to international markets.
Indonesia Seeks Better Protection Abroad
Indonesia, the largest supplier of labor to the global fishing fleet, is pursuing bilateral agreements to improve recruitment, placement and training for citizens working on foreign vessels, including those connected to Taiwan.
The Indonesian government has also issued new decrees intended to align its rules with international labor standards. Its efforts seek to protect workers' safety while taking account of the interests of foreign vessel owners.
Recruitment and employment cross national borders, so protection depends on action in more than one place. Indonesia can address how workers are recruited and prepared, while Taiwan's authorities have responsibility for enforcing standards within the fishing industry they regulate.
The effectiveness of agreements depends on whether host authorities enforce labor standards and protect migrants' rights. Workers facing debt, withheld documents or abuse need the commitments made between governments to translate into practical access to wages, safety and assistance.
What Is at Stake for Taiwan
Taiwan depends on more than 700,000 migrant workers, mostly from Southeast Asia, across sectors including elder care, manufacturing and fishing. An aging population and a shrinking workforce make their contribution increasingly important.
High brokerage fees, debt, gaps in legal protection and vulnerability to abuse extend beyond the fishing industry. The treatment of fishermen therefore sits within a broader debate over the place of migrant workers in Taiwan's economy and society.
Taiwan is often celebrated for its liberal values and human rights record. Abuse aboard its fishing vessels threatens that international standing and risks straining relations with Southeast Asian countries whose citizens supply much of its migrant workforce.
The issue also bears on Taiwan's New Southbound Policy, through which it seeks closer ties with the region. The conditions experienced by Southeast Asian workers have become a practical test of its commitment to human rights.
Arguments for stronger protections and paths to permanent settlement connect three concerns: protecting workers, responding to Taiwan's demographic pressures and improving its international standing. For fishermen such as Tangkotta, the immediate measure of progress is more concrete: receiving wages, contacting family and getting medical help when injured.
Key Points
- Taiwan's distant-water fishing fleet is the world's second-largest and relies heavily on migrant workers from Southeast Asia.
- Documented abuses include violence, wage theft, excessive working hours, recruitment debt and restrictions on leaving vessels.
- Fish from Taiwanese vessels appeared again on the U.S. forced labor list in 2023.
- Taiwan has pledged more than NT$2 billion for improvements and raised minimum monthly crew pay from US$450 to US$550.
- Unions and rights groups want common labor protections, recruitment reform, stronger inspections and secure communication at sea.
- Seafood supply chains connect the treatment of fishing crews to overseas brands, retailers and consumers.
- Indonesia is seeking stronger protection for its workers, while Taiwan faces pressure to turn reform promises into enforceable rights.






