ICC Prosecutors Push Back Against Duterte Defense Over Admissibility Challenges

6 Min Read
ICC Prosecutors Push Back Against Duterte Defense Over Admissibility Challenges

International Criminal Court prosecutors have asked judges to reject an attempt by former President Rodrigo Duterte's lawyers to challenge undisclosed material before it is formally submitted as evidence. Acting Prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang argued in a four-page public filing dated November 20 that the defense request is premature and procedurally improper. The dispute emerged from filings submitted to Trial Chamber III judges Joanna Korner, Keebong Paek, and Nicolas Guillou. Mr. Duterte faces charges of crimes against humanity relating to his tenure in the Philippines. The upcoming proceedings mark a crucial phase for accountability following years of scrutiny over extrajudicial killings.

Contents
  1. Legal Battle Unfolds Ahead of Trial
  2. Dispute Over Evidence Protocols
  3. Controversy Surrounding Witness Testimony
  4. Protecting Witnesses and Ensuring Fair Proceedings
  5. International Pressures and External Threats
  6. Timeline of Key Developments
  7. Trial Logistics and Next Steps
  8. The Essentials

Dispute Over Evidence Protocols

Prosecutors took no position on the broader issues raised before the chamber, but they asserted that the defense went beyond requested observations by seeking an undisclosed ruling in limine, which means a ruling on evidence before it is introduced during trial. The defense team reportedly contravened the court rules and a protocol established by the chamber regarding challenges to the admissibility of evidence. Under Rule 64(1) of the court regulations, parties must raise admissibility issues at the exact time when evidence is submitted to the chamber. Prosecutors also sought to correct a factual mistake made by the defense in its submission, though the public filing kept specific details redacted.

Controversy Surrounding Witness Testimony

The core of the recent defense challenge centers on a key prosecution witness identified as P-0002, who is a former Davao City Police officer and alleged member of the Davao Death Squad. Defense lawyer Peter Haynes filed a 12-page document opposing the prosecution's request to admit the prior recorded testimony of witness P-0002. Acting prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang previously sought to admit this recorded testimony because the witness is no longer available to testify. Mr. Haynes argued that admitting the recorded statements would harm the defense because lawyers cannot cross-examine the witness during the live trial. The defense also claimed that the witness made inconsistent statements and lacked probative value.

P-0002's evidence supports the existence of a policy to neutralize alleged criminals in Davao City, as shown by, (i) the provision of financial incentives; (ii) the use of State and civilian forces and (iii) the dissemination of this policy by Mr. Duterte to the perpetrators.

The testimony from witness P-0002 contains repeated references to Mr. Duterte and his alleged role in establishing the death squad, alongside supposed direct orders to commit crimes. The defense previously urged the trial chamber to dismiss testimony and evidence regarding the Davao Death Squad entirely.

Advertisement

Protecting Witnesses and Ensuring Fair Proceedings

Atty. Neri Colmenares, counsel for the victims of the drug war, supported the prosecution's request to conduct parts of the trial behind closed doors and to use pseudonyms or facial and voice distortion to protect witnesses. He explained that witnesses living in places like Davao City could face social exclusion or threats from neighbors. He noted that closed-door sessions would not violate the rights of the accused because the defense would still participate and examine evidence via video links where appropriate. The court will ultimately decide which segments remain private and how information is shared with the public.

International Pressures and External Threats

External political pressures also threaten the stability of the court as the trial date approaches. Amnesty International secretary general Agnès Callamard warned that United States sanctions against the court could imperil operations and cause the institution to collapse. The United States government has previously imposed sanctions on ICC judges and officials, including court President Tomoko Akane and senior trial lawyer Abdoulaye Seye. Plans for entity-wide sanctions could bar American funds, goods, and services to the court, affecting essential information technology services, insurance, and employee payments.

If the ICC is unable to function, the ICC will collapse. Or the trial will deliver the verdict that will have lost its credibility. At all levels, whether it's operational or political, it's bad news.

According to Ms. Callamard, powerful countries and Group of Seven states have faced demands from the United States, including no court jurisdiction over non-state parties, dropping Palestine investigations, and ensuring head of state immunities. She urged European governments to use blocking laws to protect financial transactions and institution accounts.

Advertisement

Timeline of Key Developments

  • March 2025: Former President Rodrigo Duterte is detained at the International Criminal Court in The Hague.
  • April 2025: Pre-Trial Chamber I confirms all three charges of crimes against humanity against the former president.
  • November 5, 2025: Acting prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang files a request to admit the prior recorded testimony of witness P-0002.
  • November 12, 2025: Defense files a request to reject testimony and related evidence regarding the Davao Death Squad.
  • November 18, 2025: Defense lawyer Peter Haynes files a 12-page opposition against the recorded testimony of witness P-0002.
  • November 20, 2025: Public redacted version of the prosecution response to the defense challenge is released.

Trial Logistics and Next Steps

Mr. Duterte has been detained in The Hague since March 2025 following his arrest on three counts of crimes against humanity. His case stems from the alleged killings carried out by the Davao Death Squad and a violent anti-drug campaign that resulted in thousands of deaths. Trial Chamber III previously ruled that the former president is fit to stand trial and capable of exercising his fair-trial rights. The trial is scheduled to open at the end of the month at 10 a.m. in The Hague, which corresponds to 5 p.m. in the Philippines. Judges will begin by verifying that the accused understands the charges before asking whether he admits guilt or pleads not guilty. No specific date for the final judgment has been set, with estimates suggesting the proceedings could take a year or longer.

Advertisement

The Essentials

  • Rodrigo Duterte's trial on charges of crimes against humanity of murder and attempted murder is set to open at the end of the month.
  • ICC prosecutors formally asked judges to reject a defense attempt to challenge undisclosed material before it is formally introduced.
  • The defense opposed the admission of recorded testimony from a key witness identified as P-0002, citing a lack of cross-examination opportunities.
  • Amnesty International warned that external United States sanctions against the international tribunal could threaten the proceedings.
  • Proceedings will begin at 10 a.m. in The Hague, where judges will verify that the accused understands the charges and record his plea.
Share This Article

You May also Like