Sara Duterte Impeachment Trial Puts Cale88's Money and Records Under Scrutiny

11 Min Read
Sara Duterte Impeachment Trial Puts Cale88's Money and Records Under Scrutiny

A company's registration is only part of the dispute

On November 20, 2026, the 45th day of Vice President Sara Duterte's impeachment trial, a senior trade official confirmed that the Board of Investments found no problem with Cale88 Foods Corp.'s exports to China under the export rules it checks. Yet Department of Trade and Industry Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo could not explain why records cited in the trial showed about ₱776 million in cash inflows to the banana chips company against ₱208 million in declared sales.

Contents
  1. A company's registration is only part of the dispute
  2. What did the trade official confirm?
  3. Why are the money figures drawing scrutiny?
  4. How many workers did Cale88 have?
  5. What did the witness say about the company's name and incentives?
  6. Why do prosecutors say registration is not enough?
  7. What is at stake in the trial's pace?
  8. Why was Duterte's spokesperson ordered to explain his remarks?
  9. Key Points

The gap, about ₱568 million using figures cited by prosecutors, has become a central point of contention. Cale88 is linked to Duterte's husband, lawyer Manases Carpio. The defense called Rodolfo to describe the company's registration and business records. Prosecutors and senator judges pressed him on what those records did, and did not, explain about the money and the company's workforce.

The trial concerns Article II of the impeachment articles, which alleges Duterte accumulated unexplained wealth and failed to declare it in her Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Net Worth. Lead prosecutor Gerville Luistro said the defense's slow presentation of witnesses and requests to defer hearings supported the prosecution's earlier choice to stop pursuing three of the four articles and focus on Article II. She said prosecutors had announced the decision in open court on October 13 and that continuing with all four would have taken more trial time.

For readers following the case, the key distinction is straightforward: a business can be registered and meet an export rule while questions remain about whether its reported sales match the money entering its accounts. Rodolfo addressed the first issue within the limits of his agency's checks. He said he could not account for the second.

What did the trade official confirm?

Rodolfo, who also heads the BOI, testified that the agency approved Cale88's registration on December 9, 2021, as an export enterprise. To qualify, a company must export at least 70 percent of its products or production value. The BOI's focus, he said, was whether Cale88 met that threshold, not which country bought its goods.

Documents presented by the defense included certificates of inward remittance, which identify companies that sent money to Cale88, and lists of exports, sales volumes and values. Rodolfo said the documents helped show the company's customers and establish export earnings. The company's BOI records included exports in 2023 of 216,000 kilograms of banana chips worth ₱23.6 million.

When defense lawyer Justin Gular asked whether the BOI found irregularities in Cale88's China related exports, Rodolfo said the agency checked the 70 percent export requirement and answered yes when asked whether it found an issue with the exports under that requirement. That finding describes the scope of the BOI's review. Rodolfo said he was unaware of the Anti Money Laundering Council's findings and could not explain why the remittances cited in the trial were higher than the company's declared sales.

Rodolfo also confirmed that the BOI approved Cale88 as a small or medium sized enterprise and that the company had received a certificate of good standing. The defense used this testimony to support its account that the company was a real, registered exporter. Prosecutors replied that registration was not the question they wanted answered.

Advertisement

Why are the money figures drawing scrutiny?

Senator judge Win Gatchalian compared roughly ₱208 million in audited sales from 2022 to 2025 with approximately ₱776 million in inward remittances over the period, citing figures presented in the trial. The AMLC figures were also described as including ₱319 million from China. Separate figures put Cale88's paid up capital at ₱125,000.

Rodolfo said he saw no reason in the company documents submitted to the BOI for inward remittances to exceed declared sales. He said it was the first time he had encountered such a discrepancy and that company officers, including its president, treasurer and export sales manager, would be better placed to explain the numbers. When senator judge Bam Aquino asked who could answer, Rodolfo named the company's owners and officers, including part owner Lourdes Lebosada.

Prosecutors have described the unexplained portion in different ways, including a roughly ₱568 million gap between declared sales of ₱208.4 million and bank inflows of ₱776.6 million. House prosecutor Zia Alonto Adiong also cited a forensic analyst's calculation that 51 percent of Cale88's income from 2002 to 2025 was undeclared. He said that figure exceeded a 30 percent threshold that he described as prima facie evidence of fraud. Those are prosecution claims presented as part of the impeachment case; the defense has said it will call witnesses to address the company's operations and earnings.

AMLC Executive Director Ronel Buenaventura previously told the impeachment court that the unaccounted funds could provide a starting point for a possible money laundering investigation. Senator judge Panfilo Lacson said he wanted records such as waybills and shipping documents to test whether the money corresponded to actual shipments. The defense has said Rodolfo's testimony was preliminary and that other witnesses would answer questions about the transactions.

Advertisement

How many workers did Cale88 have?

The company's workforce records produced another sharp discrepancy. Rodolfo said BOI records listed 201 employees in 2024 and 50 in 2025. He said the company attributed the fall to a management change and a period when it was not operating.

However, Cale88's Securities and Exchange Commission filings showed no rank and file employees or manpower complement in its 2024 General Information Sheet. Its 2025 filing listed two officers and two employees. Rodolfo confirmed those details during questioning. A General Information Sheet is a company filing that identifies its owners and officers, among other information.

Rodolfo said the BOI did not automatically require employee lists from registered firms unless they applied for incentives. He had not seen Cale88's Social Security System or PhilHealth submissions. He also said he had no personal knowledge of the company's actual operations or whether a building it reported as 90 percent complete had been finished. The different employee counts therefore come from different records: the BOI's figures and the company's filings.

The ownership documents also changed over time. Cale88's 2024 filing listed Carpio and Lebosada with 47.5 percent each, and Mairi Liano with 5 percent. Carpio was not listed in the 2025 filing. Documents shown in the proceedings also indicated that the company later transferred 95 percent of its shares to Pikimong Pikimong Philippines Corp. The trial testimony did not provide a full explanation of the changes.

What did the witness say about the company's name and incentives?

Rodolfo said the name Cale88 combines parts of the surnames of Carpio and Lebosada, while 88 represents infinity, based on information from the BOI's Davao office. The company was co founded in 2012, according to records discussed during the hearing.

Senator judge Sherwin Gatchalian asked why Cale88 had not applied for value added tax zero rating, a tax treatment that can apply to qualifying exports. Rodolfo said he did not know. The defense also questioned him about tree planting requirements for some businesses seeking BOI incentives. Prosecutor Erwin Matib asked if Duterte's tree planting activities were connected to Cale88's compliance, and raised a requirement for enterprises to plant at least 100 forest trees.

Rodolfo said he had not personally seen Duterte plant trees and could not confirm whether Cale88 submitted a notarized compliance statement. He added that Cale88 had not sought incentives that would have required BOI compliance checks. Gular objected to Matib's line of questioning as misleading, saying there was no earlier testimony connecting Duterte's tree planting to the company. Presiding Officer Francis Escudero sustained the objection.

Senator judge Imee Marcos asked whether the BOI had found evidence that Cale88 was fictitious or had inflated its export figures. Rodolfo said there was no indication of that, while adding he could not judge whether its business model was implausible. The Food and Drug Administration also confirmed Cale88's registration and displayed photographs of its banana chip products during the proceedings. Prosecutors have argued that product registration and pictures do not answer questions about the scale of its business or the money it received.

Advertisement

Why do prosecutors say registration is not enough?

House prosecutor Joel Chua and prosecution spokesperson Alonto Adiong said Cale88's registration was not the core issue. Their concern is whether income linked to the company was declared and whether the money entering its accounts can be explained. Chua cited about ₱1.1 billion in transactions and said ₱319 million came from China, while prosecutors have pointed to roughly ₱776 million in inflows that they say remain unaccounted for.

The AMLC figures have prompted questions about the identity of Cale88's overseas customers. Senator judge Risa Hontiveros said her office had examined two companies that transacted with Cale88: China National Township Enterprises and Beijing Jianweifang Food Company. She said the first had been directly under China's Ministry of Agriculture and that the second was owned by a Chinese state owned group. AMLC officials previously confirmed the money transfers cited in the trial, while Duterte's lawyers secured confirmation that no document presented to the court showed the Chinese government was involved with Cale88.

In October, the National Security Council said it would look into reported Chinese funds flowing to the company. Deputy Speaker Jefferson Khonghun said lawmakers were calling for an investigation into Cale88. These inquiries concern the company's transactions and possible explanations for them; the impeachment court is weighing whether the evidence bears on the allegation about Duterte's declared wealth.

The defense has stressed that Cale88 is owned by Carpio and business partners, not directly by Duterte. Prosecutors have countered that the company's finances matter to the Article II allegation because they say its income may relate to unexplained wealth. Cale88 appeared in Duterte's asset declarations from 2022 to 2025, according to information presented in the trial.

What is at stake in the trial's pace?

Luistro criticized the defense for taking long stretches to present testimony she considered relevant to the impeachment allegations. She said prosecutors had weighed several factors before dropping three articles, including the Senate's legislative work. The defense, in turn, said its witnesses were unavailable on November 26 and 27 and rejected the claim that it was deliberately prolonging the case.

Defense spokesperson Michael Poa said more witnesses would explain Cale88's operations and earnings. Luistro said she hoped the defense would provide a list of witnesses whose testimony directly addressed the disputed issues. Prosecutor Terry Ridon said the previous two weeks of defense evidence had been spent on "non-issues" and said he hoped Carpio and Lebosada would testify.

The defense dispensed with the planned testimony of lawyer Eva Marie Mariquina of the Center for International Trade Expositions and Missions. The impeachment court adjourned on November 20 and scheduled hearings for December 1 to 4 and December 7 to 11, with December 14 to 17 reserved if needed. Hearings were set for 10 a.m. to 3 p.m.

Advertisement

Why was Duterte's spokesperson ordered to explain his remarks?

The court also ordered Duterte spokesperson lawyer Salvador Paolo Panelo Jr. to show why he should not be held in contempt under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court. Senator judge Erwin Tulfo sought the order after Panelo accused some senator judges of bias. Panelo had singled out Tulfo, Francis Pangilinan and Risa Hontiveros, arguing that challenging defense witnesses' credibility was not their role.

Escudero noted that Panelo was not listed as a member of Duterte's legal team, but said he could be asked to explain his comments. Panelo maintained that his remarks were protected by freedom of expression and the public's right to criticize judicial authorities.

Impeachment court spokesperson Regie Tongol said Panelo's remarks would not affect the senator judges' final decision on factual and legal issues. Tongol also said the court could protect its integrity if statements risked disorder or led one side to reject its rulings. The show cause order asks Panelo to explain himself; it is not itself a finding of contempt.

Key Points

  • The impeachment trial's remaining article alleges Sara Duterte had unexplained wealth and failed to declare it.

  • The BOI approved Cale88 as an export enterprise, with a rule requiring at least 70 percent of production to be exported.

  • Rodolfo could not explain the roughly ₱776 million in inflows compared with about ₱208 million in declared sales.

  • BOI workforce records listed 201 employees in 2024 and 50 in 2025, while company filings listed no rank and file staff in 2024 and two employees in 2025.

  • The trial was scheduled to resume December 1, with further hearings planned through December 11 and, if needed, December 14 to 17.

  • The court ordered Duterte spokesperson Paolo Panelo to explain remarks alleging bias among senator judges.

Share This Article

You May also Like