A new chapter would put seized property under closer scrutiny
China's proposed fourth revision of its Criminal Procedure Law would require courts to decide what happens to property frozen or seized during criminal cases, bar the return of confiscation revenue to investigating agencies, and give prosecutors greater oversight of police decisions affecting valuable assets.
Contents
- A new chapter would put seized property under closer scrutiny
- What property could investigators restrict?
- Factories could keep using essential equipment
- Cutting the financial incentive behind enforcement
- Why policing across regional boundaries draws concern
- Courts would have to decide the fate of assets
- Owners outside the case would gain a clearer voice
- Prosecutors would receive notice after major seizures
- Property safeguards sit within a wider rights revision
- How the revision reached this stage
- Key Points
The draft adds a dedicated chapter on handling property involved in criminal proceedings. It addresses complaints that investigations can sweep up legitimate business funds, family savings and property belonging to people outside a case, sometimes leaving factories unable to operate long before a court delivers a verdict.
The 55 article amendment received its first reading at the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, according to the Ministry of Justice's November 4 account. The draft was subsequently published for public comment. It remains a proposal, and no adoption date or consultation deadline was specified in the accounts of the revision.
The property provisions take aim at a particularly contentious practice: officials pursuing cases outside their own regions to obtain money or assets. In China, critics describe this as "distant ocean fishing", a metaphor for reaching into another locality in search of financial returns.
The proposal combines several responses rather than relying on a single prohibition. Investigators would have to establish who owns property and how it relates to a crime; prosecutors would receive notice of consequential seizures; courts would have to resolve property questions; and confiscation proceeds could not be linked to an agency's funding.
What property could investigators restrict?
The draft requires authorities to distinguish criminal proceeds from other property connected to a case and from lawful assets. It also separates a company's property from its operator's personal possessions, a suspect's assets from those of outsiders, and an individual's property from that of family members.
Those categories matter in cases involving many investors, including illegal fundraising investigations. A broad freeze can affect money belonging to several different people or businesses, although their legal positions may be very different.
Sealing property generally restricts its use or transfer, seizure places it under official control, and freezing blocks access to assets such as bank funds. Each can preserve evidence or money needed to resolve a case. Each can also interrupt daily life or business before ownership and liability have been settled.
The proposed rules require authorities to protect lawful property rights and reduce disruption to normal business. The practical task would be to identify the assets needed for the case rather than restricting everything associated with a suspect.
Factories could keep using essential equipment
Factories, machinery and other production assets receive specific attention. Where proceedings can continue normally, the draft would allow the people concerned to keep making reasonable use of sealed or seized business property, with necessary measures to preserve its value and keep it safe.
A machine can be both an asset relevant to an investigation and the equipment workers need to make products. Leaving it idle for a lengthy period can interrupt wages, deliveries and payments to suppliers. Freezing operating funds can have similar effects across a company's business relationships.
The proposal also provides for centralized custody of property and disposal before a case ends in specified circumstances. Those provisions address the management of assets while criminal proceedings are still under way, alongside the question of their final destination.
Permission to continue using production assets would depend on the needs of the proceedings. The proposal therefore places a concrete decision before authorities: how to keep property available for the case while allowing legitimate activity to continue.
Cutting the financial incentive behind enforcement
The draft's funding restrictions address a longstanding concern about confiscation revenue. Under the existing law, illicit money, goods and the income they generate must go to the state treasury, apart from property lawfully returned to victims.
The proposed wording would prohibit any organization or individual from diverting or independently disposing of those assets. It would also prohibit spending confiscation receipts directly, returning them to case handling agencies openly or through indirect arrangements, or linking them to funding for investigations.
The Ministry of Finance's 2020 Measures for the Administration of Confiscated Property already require enforcement budgets to be funded through the relevant government's budget. They also prohibit linking an agency's budget allocation to the confiscation revenue it submits in any year.
In practice, arrangements described in the legal debate have allowed local treasuries to return money through spending allocations tied to agencies' enforcement contributions or local conventions. Such arrangements can reward agencies for generating confiscation income. Financial pressure on local governments has made concern about those incentives more acute.
The proposed criminal procedure provisions would reinforce the separation between enforcement and revenue. Scholars also argue that restrictions must reach the finance departments making allocations, because criminal procedure rules chiefly regulate police, prosecutors and courts.
Why policing across regional boundaries draws concern
A case publicized by the Zhejiang provincial procuratorate illustrates the personal risks of abusive enforcement. In 2023, a police officer surnamed Yang and an auxiliary officer surnamed Zhan took an entrepreneur surnamed Shen from his home in Wujiang, Jiangsu, ostensibly to assist an investigation.
During the journey, Yang suggested he could help resolve the case and sought money. Shen escaped by jumping from the vehicle when the two were distracted and reported the incident. A court later sentenced both men for abuse of power.
The draft would require police carrying out sealing, seizure or freezing in another locality to notify police where the property is located. That would bring the local force into the process when officers act beyond their home area.
Jurisdiction, the legal authority to investigate a case, remains another focus of debate. Rules issued in 2022 by the Supreme People's Court, Supreme People's Procuratorate and Ministry of Public Security give several places a connection to an online crime. They include locations of servers, service providers, affected information systems, victims and financial losses.
Lawyers argue that these many connections give investigators wide scope to claim authority as business moves online. Their proposed response is tighter jurisdiction rules, alongside the draft's requirements governing how property is restricted and handled.
Courts would have to decide the fate of assets
The draft would require a court's judgment to address seized, sealed and frozen property and any income it has generated. That responds to complaints that some judgments handle property vaguely or leave its destination unresolved.
Scholars describe cases in which courts avoid detailed property decisions because carrying them out would be difficult, potentially affecting measures of judgment enforcement. For owners, a criminal judgment that leaves property questions open can mean continued uncertainty over access to money or equipment.
The proposed process begins much earlier than sentencing. Investigators would have to collect evidence of an asset's ownership, nature, origin, use and value. They would also have to establish its relationship to the alleged crime and the suspect.
Police forwarding a case for prosecution review, and prosecutors bringing charges, would have to provide specific recommendations for handling the property. During trial, the court would examine evidence and hear argument about matters including ownership and the nature of the assets.
That sequence would make property a question to be investigated, argued and decided throughout the case, rather than an administrative issue left until the criminal charges have been resolved.
Owners outside the case would gain a clearer voice
Family members, business partners and other people with an interest in restricted assets could object to their sealing, seizure, freezing or disposal. Police, prosecutors and courts would have to verify those objections promptly, hear the interested person's views and handle the matter according to law.
Courts could notify interested people to attend hearings when necessary. This would give someone whose property has been affected an opportunity to explain ownership even when that person is not accused of a crime.
Scholars regard the proposal as stronger protection for outsiders than the changes adopted in 2012. Some want it to go further by granting these owners formal party status for the property portion of proceedings and an explicit right to appoint a lawyer.
The central practical issue is access to the process. A person seeking the return of property needs a way to present documents, challenge an incorrect ownership claim and receive a decision while the criminal case proceeds.
Prosecutors would receive notice after major seizures
Police would have to send relevant decisions and notices to the procuratorate at the same level when restricted property is especially valuable or the measure has a major effect on the person concerned. Prosecutors finding an error would have to notify police promptly to correct it.
China's procuratorates both prosecute criminal cases and supervise the legality of aspects of criminal proceedings. Scholars say their supervision of asset restrictions has been difficult when police control both investigation and the initial approval of measures, leaving prosecutors unaware of an excessive seizure.
The draft introduces mandatory notification in consequential cases. Liu Jihua, a law professor at Renmin University of China, argues for review before police act, comparable to the prosecutorial review required for arrests. Under his proposal, police would need prosecutorial approval before restricting the property.
The current draft instead provides supervision after the decision in the specified circumstances. The difference matters for a business whose funds or equipment have already become unavailable by the time a prosecutor examines the measure.
Du Xueyi, director of the Supreme People's Procuratorate's economic crime prosecution department, has said the procuratorate is leading work on guidance to strengthen supervision of measures including sealing, seizure and freezing. Consultation with relevant bodies has taken place, and work toward publication and implementation is continuing.
Property safeguards sit within a wider rights revision
The amendment also addresses detention, proceedings involving foreign elements, and protections for victims, lawyers and juveniles. The Ministry of Justice says it seeks to give court hearings a substantive role and ensure that courts, prosecutors and police check one another while performing their respective duties.
The proposal adds an express prohibition on presuming guilt to the existing rule that nobody may be found guilty without a lawful court judgment. The intended change concerns how officials investigate and prosecute before a verdict, including whether they consider evidence pointing away from guilt.
Another major provision would limit residential surveillance at a designated location to cases involving national security offenses or terrorist activities. The current framework also allows the measure when a person has no fixed residence.
The debate follows deaths during designated residential surveillance, including that of Bao Qinrui in 2022 and Xing Yanjun in 2024. Scholars have called for stronger supervision of designated locations, access to lawyers and procedures for seeking a change or termination of the measure.
The legislative report describes a changing pattern of crime: serious violence and the proportion of offenders receiving heavy sentences have declined, while minor offenses have increased and some crimes have moved online or across borders. The police authority says criminal cases nationwide fell 12.8 percent in 2025.
How the revision reached this stage
China adopted the Criminal Procedure Law in 1979 and has revised it three times. The present proposal arrives eight years after the last revision and would bring property handling into a dedicated chapter.
- 1979: China adopted the Criminal Procedure Law.
- 1996 and 2012: The first two revisions expanded the procedural framework.
- 2018: The third revision was adopted.
- 2020: Finance Ministry rules prohibited linking enforcement budgets to confiscation revenue.
- 2022: Rules on online crime procedures set out multiple geographic grounds for jurisdiction.
- 2026: The fourth amendment received its first legislative reading and was released for public comment.
Liu's comparison of the revisions counts 16 net additional provisions in the current draft, bringing the proposed law to 324 articles. The amendment's 55 articles include changes to existing provisions as well as additions.
The decisions now before lawmakers concern both the reach of the protections and how they would operate: whether prosecutors should review seizures before they happen, how owners outside a case can defend their interests, and how funding rules can remove financial rewards for enforcement.
Key Points
- The draft adds a dedicated chapter on property involved in criminal cases and requires courts to decide its disposal.
- Authorities would have to distinguish lawful assets, company property, family property and assets belonging to outsiders.
- Production equipment could remain in reasonable use when proceedings can continue normally.
- Confiscation revenue could not be returned to investigating agencies or linked to their funding.
- Major asset restrictions would trigger notice to prosecutors, while scholars seek review before police act.
- The wider amendment addresses presumption of innocence, detention and designated residential surveillance.
- The proposal remains under legislative consideration following its first reading and publication for comment.






