Indonesia's Mini House Proposal Faces Backlash Over Space, Health and Housing Rights

14 Min Read
Micro Housing Proves That Affordable Architecture Can Be Beautiful

Rp 100 Million Homes Put Living Space at the Center of the Debate

Indonesia's proposal for subsidized homes as small as 14 square meters has drawn criticism from architects, urban planners, lawmakers and young people, even as the government presents it as a response to a housing shortage of nearly 10 million units. As of June 20, 2025, the proposal remains under discussion, with the Public Housing and Settlements Ministry saying it is seeking public feedback before making a final decision.

Contents
  1. Rp 100 Million Homes Put Living Space at the Center of the Debate
  2. What Would Buyers Get?
  3. How the Proposal Compares With Existing Standards
  4. Lawmakers and Architects Challenge the Design
  5. Why Planners Fear Spatial Poverty
  6. Can the Homes Adapt to Growing Families?
  7. Young Residents Question the Tradeoff
  8. The Housing Shortage Behind the Government's Push
  9. Expensive Urban Land Shapes the Proposal
  10. Apartments and Transit Offer Other Approaches
  11. How the Debate Reached This Point
  12. Key Points

Two prototypes displayed at a South Jakarta mall show what the policy could mean for residents. The smallest offers one bedroom, a living area and a bathroom within 14 square meters, on a plot measuring 25 square meters. A second model has two bedrooms and 23.4 square meters of floor space on a 26.3 square meter plot. Prices range from Rp 100 million to Rp 140 million, equivalent to US$6,121 to US$8,570.

The ministry, working with property developer Lippo Group, intends the homes for Jakarta and the surrounding cities of Bekasi, Bogor, Depok and Tangerang. Its target is young urban residents, particularly Generation Z, who want an affordable home near work but face property prices beyond their reach.

Opponents say the proposed savings come at too high a cost. Their concerns range from insufficient space and ventilation to family stress, neighborhoods that may deteriorate and a retreat from existing housing standards. The argument is about both access to ownership and whether the homes would give residents enough room to live comfortably as their needs change.

What Would Buyers Get?

The prototypes offer a very small amount of interior space, with the larger model dividing 23.4 square meters between two bedrooms and other household needs. Both designs also include a carport nearly as large as the interior living area. Critics have questioned why parking receives so much space when residents would have so little.

Urban Housing Director Sri Haryati explained on Monday that the smaller homes were meant to attract young people, particularly Gen Z residents seeking minimalist, affordable accommodation close to their workplaces. The government's argument is that some young professionals would accept less floor space in exchange for a convenient urban location and a lower purchase price.

A 2024 survey by consulting firm Inventure Indonesia illustrates the difficulty facing that audience: two out of three Gen Z respondents were pessimistic about buying a house within the next three years because of rising prices. The proposed price range seeks to reach people who feel excluded from ownership, although the small rooms have prompted objections from potential buyers as well as housing specialists.

Advertisement

Public Housing and Settlements Minister Maruarar Sirait has said the concept came from private developers. He has also said that many young people he has spoken to place greater value on a prime location than on a large home. The ministry says the smaller option would be restricted to dense urban centers, while rural housing would retain the existing, larger standards.

How the Proposal Compares With Existing Standards

A 2023 decree from the Public Works and Housing Ministry sets a minimum building area of 21 square meters for a subsidized house, on a plot measuring between 60 and 200 square meters. The proposed policy would reduce those minimums to an 18 square meter building and a 25 square meter plot.

The 14 square meter display unit is smaller still, falling below both the existing 21 square meter minimum and the proposed 18 square meter minimum. The larger prototype exceeds those building minimums, but its 26.3 square meter plot remains much smaller than the existing minimum of 60 square meters. The prototype dimensions and the proposed regulatory thresholds therefore describe different parts of the plan.

Critics also point to wider measures of adequate living space. The United Nations Human Settlements Programme, UN-Habitat, recommends a minimum of 30 square meters per house. Indonesia's technical guidelines from 2002 suggest at least 7.2 square meters per person, making 21.6 square meters the minimum for a family of three. The World Health Organization benchmark cited in the debate is an ideal of 12 square meters per person.

Using the Indonesian figure, three people sharing the smallest prototype would have about 4.7 square meters each, compared with the guideline of 7.2. Three people in the larger model would have 7.8 square meters each. Those calculations show why household size matters: a dwelling intended for one young worker may face different demands when a partner or children move in.

Architects and other critics say the designs also lack sufficient natural lighting and cross ventilation. Cross ventilation allows air to enter through one opening and leave through another, helping air move through a home. Their objections concern the quality of the space as well as its size.

Lawmakers and Architects Challenge the Design

Yanuar Arif Wibowo, a member of House Commission V, challenged the idea that Indonesia needed to accept such restricted living conditions. Speaking at a forum, he compared the proposal with housing pressures in Hong Kong:

We are not Hong Kong. We still have land. Don't reduce housing to permanent cages.

Trubus Rahadiansyah, a public policy expert at Trisakti University, argued that reducing the existing minimum would make an already cramped situation worse:

Even 21 square meters is already too cramped. Reducing it further is inhumane.

Advertisement

The Indonesian Institute of Architects, known as IAI, has also opposed the proposal. Its chairman, Georgius Budi Yulianto, described the practical and emotional demands a home must accommodate:

Eighteen square meters is half the size of a garage. Where do you cry in peace, or let your child play, or simply breathe?

These objections put everyday activities at the center of the discussion. A home must accommodate sleeping and washing, but residents also need places to study, spend time together, play and find privacy. Critics argue that an affordable purchase becomes a poor housing solution when those activities cannot fit comfortably inside.

Why Planners Fear Spatial Poverty

Urban planning observer Yayat Supriatna warned that the policy could create a "new poverty cycle." His concern is that residents would exchange one form of hardship, being unable to afford property, for another that he called "spatial poverty": having too little room for ordinary life.

Yayat argued that the government's approach focuses on economics while giving insufficient attention to the psychological and social effects of cramped conditions. A lower price can make ownership possible, but the people buying the house must continue living with its layout every day.

Critics warn that confining a family to a space smaller than a typical hotel room could contribute to chronic stress, domestic conflict and fewer opportunities for personal development. Children need space to grow, study and play, while adults need privacy and room to maintain relationships. These are concerns about what could happen if the housing is built and occupied under the proposed conditions.

Georgius warned that tension arising from limited space could create "fragile and aggressive social ties." His concern extends beyond individual households to relationships across a neighborhood. If many families struggle with the same lack of room, the pressure could affect community life as well as conditions inside each home.

Can the Homes Adapt to Growing Families?

Tulus Abadi, chairman of the Indonesian Empowered Consumers Forum, or FKBI, questioned how the houses would serve residents over time. A small home purchased by a young person may later need to accommodate a spouse, children and the changing requirements of family life.

Tulus warned that families unable to fit into the homes could eventually leave them. He said this could produce neighborhoods with empty, deteriorating dwellings, adding a new urban problem instead of providing a lasting answer to the existing housing shortage.

Explaining his opposition, Tulus described decent housing as a right tied to several parts of a person's life:

This proposal represents a step backward in the fulfillment of the right to a decent home. A house is not just a shelter. It is a space that supports physical health, emotional stability, family life and overall well-being.

Advertisement

The criticism concerns the useful life of the proposed homes. The government is targeting young buyers, but ownership is a lasting commitment. Tulus argues that a house should remain suitable as the household changes, rather than force residents to find somewhere else once their need for space grows.

Young Residents Question the Tradeoff

Public criticism has included ridicule on social media, where the proposal has been called "rumah subsi-DIE." The phrase plays on the Indonesian word for subsidy, "subsidi," and the English word "die," expressing a bleak view of the living conditions the homes could offer.

Rahma, a university student from Depok who viewed the display unit, gave a more personal account of her reaction. Speaking to reporters, she said:

I saw the display [unit], and I couldn't even imagine stretching out comfortably in it.

Rahma said she would prefer to keep renting a larger space rather than buy a home that could compromise her physical and mental health. Her response challenges the ministry's assumption that young people will accept very small interiors to gain ownership in a convenient location.

The Inventure survey shows widespread pessimism about buying property among the Gen Z respondents it questioned. Rahma's reaction brings out another part of the issue: an affordable price is one consideration, while the experience of living in the house is another. For her, more space in a rented home was preferable to ownership of the displayed unit.

The Housing Shortage Behind the Government's Push

Indonesia's official housing backlog stands at 9.9 million units, while other estimates put the shortage as high as 15 million. About 80 percent of the shortage is concentrated in urban areas, where demand for homes meets particularly expensive land.

The administration has set a target of building three million homes by 2025. Meeting that ambition requires a scale of construction far beyond the small prototypes at the center of the debate, and the funding available is a major constraint.

The state has allocated Rp 5 trillion, equivalent to about US$308 million, toward the goal. That sum is estimated to fund only 8 percent of the target. Using the three million figure, 8 percent amounts to about 240,000 homes, leaving the government heavily dependent on private developers and other funding to reach its ambition.

Smaller houses offer a straightforward attraction for a program focused on numbers: cheaper individual units can allow more homes to be built with limited resources. Critics argue that counting completed units gives an incomplete picture of success unless the homes also provide adequate living conditions.

The shortage helps explain the urgency of the ministry's proposal. Millions of households need housing, and young urban residents face prices that many believe they cannot meet. The dispute is over how the government should respond to that pressure and what minimum quality a subsidized home should provide.

Advertisement

Expensive Urban Land Shapes the Proposal

Maruarar Sirait has identified land prices as a central obstacle to subsidized housing in major cities. Explaining the difficulty to reporters, the minister said:

You can't find subsidized homes in Jakarta or Bandung. Why? Because land is too expensive.

The ministry sees smaller plots and buildings as a way to bring ownership within reach in locations where young people want to live. Jakarta and its surrounding cities combine strong demand for housing with high land costs, making location a central part of the proposed compromise.

Maruarar says the displayed prototypes are intended to gather public feedback, and the ministry has not finalized its decision. The urban restriction is also part of its stated approach: the smaller option would apply in dense centers, with current standards retained for rural housing.

The policy debate therefore involves several choices at once: how much space buyers receive, where homes are built, how subsidies are used and whether developments can serve their residents over time. Critics say those choices should be addressed together rather than resolved mainly by shrinking the house and its plot.

Apartments and Transit Offer Other Approaches

Tulus Abadi and Trubus Rahadiansyah have urged the government to focus more on affordable apartments and taller residential buildings. Their argument is that stacking homes on several floors can accommodate more households on a limited area of land without requiring each household's interior space to shrink to the same degree.

Trubus framed that alternative directly, linking the choice of building type to the amount of space residents would receive:

For units below 21 square meters, it's better to go vertical. Land is limited, but dignity shouldn't be.

Anwar Basil Arifin, head of research at the urban advocacy platform Menemukenali Project, has proposed a focus on transit-oriented development, or TOD. This means placing dense residential and commercial development around major public transport hubs, connecting homes with workplaces and services through accessible transport.

Anwar's approach addresses the desire to live near work through connections as well as physical proximity. Such development can reduce reliance on cars and the need to devote scarce land to large carports, while supporting walking and connected communities.

Advertisement

Describing his view of the problem, Anwar argued that the response needed to go beyond the price of individual homes:

Jakarta's housing crisis isn't just a market failure, it is a crisis of urban design and imagination.

The alternatives put the arrangement of housing and transport at the center of the discussion. Critics argue that Indonesia can make better use of urban land through apartments and access to transit, rather than treating extremely small landed houses as the principal route to affordable ownership.

How the Debate Reached This Point

The controversy draws on standards and affordability concerns developed over several years. The relevant dates show how the proposed reduction in space fits into the existing policy setting:

  • 2002: Indonesian technical guidelines suggested a minimum living space of 7.2 square meters per person.
  • 2023: A Public Works and Housing Ministry decree set subsidized housing plots at 60 to 200 square meters, with buildings of at least 21 square meters.
  • 2024: An Inventure Indonesia survey found that two out of three Gen Z respondents were pessimistic about buying a house within three years because of rising prices.
  • 2025: The administration's three million home target and the proposed smaller urban homes brought the tension between construction numbers and living conditions into focus.
  • June 20, 2025: The mini house proposal remained under discussion, with the ministry gathering feedback and no final decision announced.

The housing debate also comes amid criticism of another government policy, a subsidy scheme for journalists that press organizations rejected on ethical grounds. That dispute concerned a different part of housing policy, but it also reflected disagreement over how assistance should be designed and accepted by its intended recipients.

For the mini house proposal, the central choice is whether lower prices and more completed units can be achieved while protecting adequate space, health and family life. Critics warn that a rush to meet construction targets could create lasting social problems and poor living conditions, including vertical slums if taller housing is also developed without sufficient attention to quality.

The ministry's stated goal is to make ownership possible for people priced out of urban housing. The objections ask it to achieve that goal through homes and neighborhoods that remain livable. As of June 20, the government was still weighing those competing demands.

Key Points

  • Indonesia is considering subsidized urban homes priced at Rp 100 million to Rp 140 million, with a displayed unit as small as 14 square meters.
  • The prototypes target young residents in Jakarta, Bekasi, Bogor, Depok and Tangerang.
  • The proposed minimums of 18 square meters for buildings and 25 square meters for plots are below the existing subsidized housing thresholds.
  • The official housing backlog is 9.9 million units, with about 80 percent of the shortage concentrated in urban areas.
  • Architects, planners, lawmakers and potential residents have raised concerns about ventilation, privacy, family needs and long term neighborhood conditions.
  • Critics propose affordable apartments and development around public transport hubs as alternatives.
  • The ministry had not finalized the proposal as of June 20, 2025, and said it was seeking public feedback.
Share This Article

You May also Like