A debate about propulsion, deterrence and Japan's nuclear rules
Japan's government is preparing to put a formal review of submarines powered by nuclear reactors into its revised security plans, with a draft calling for officials to begin consideration and reach a decision at an early stage. The three documents are due for revision by the end of December. Research could begin in the first years of the fiscal period running from 2027 through 2031, with money set aside for research and study rather than an immediate purchase.
Contents
- A debate about propulsion, deterrence and Japan's nuclear rules
- What would the draft set in motion?
- Why are officials considering a reactor powered submarine?
- What advantages and drawbacks does the navy identify?
- How large could the bill become?
- The coalition agrees on missiles, not on the engine
- What does the plan mean for Japan's nuclear principles?
- Public opposition adds pressure to the discussion
- How does the argument look beyond Tokyo?
- Key Points
The choice under discussion is whether the Self-Defense Forces should acquire submarines whose reactors power their movement. These are different from submarines carrying nuclear weapons. However, the debate is unfolding alongside a separate proposal to allow nuclear weapons to enter Japan in an emergency, creating concern that both questions could affect the country's long-standing nuclear policy.
Supporters say reactor powered submarines could stay submerged for longer, travel faster underwater and patrol distant parts of the Pacific. Critics point to high costs, technical and staffing needs, legal questions and the risk of shifting Japan's undersea force toward missions that look more offensive. The draft would begin a review; it would not itself order the construction of a submarine.
What would the draft set in motion?
The government's three security documents are the National Security Strategy, the National Defense Strategy and the Defense Buildup Program. Together, they set broad goals, describe military plans and outline equipment and spending priorities. The revision is intended to be settled by a Cabinet decision before the end of December, after discussions among ruling parties and a report from an expert panel.
Draft language calls for the government to "launch consideration" of the submarines and reach a conclusion "at an early stage." Officials are also weighing wording that says "early conclusion," making the timing of the decision itself part of the political discussion. The contemplated research program would start in the early part of the 2027 to 2031 period, with funding recorded as research and study expenses.
A Brookings analysis explains why the exact wording matters: a promise to consider or research a capability is not the same as a commitment to acquire it. The draft could therefore open a policy process while leaving the final choice, design and timing unsettled.
Why are officials considering a reactor powered submarine?
Japan's government points to China's expanding naval activity in the Pacific and North Korea's work on submarine development. The argument made by supporters is that conventional submarines face limits when they need to patrol far from home for long periods. A reactor lets a submarine remain underwater for extended periods without surfacing to take in air for its engines, and can provide high underwater speed.
Those features could help with surveillance, tracking ships and submarines, and moving away quickly after a launch. Supporters also see the submarines as a possible platform for missiles launched from vertical tubes, which would allow attacks from a concealed position. They argue that an opponent would have to consider the possibility that a submarine could be nearby, strengthening deterrence.
Japan's Defense Minister Shinjiro Koizumi has said the government has not decided to acquire the vessels, while keeping the option in the discussion. Koizumi described the approach as not excluding any options. Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi told parliament in October that the government would hold "concrete and realistic discussions" about the possibility.
What advantages and drawbacks does the navy identify?
Admiral Akira Saito, chief of staff of the Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force, said the navy was not yet at a point where it could give a conclusion on whether the vessels were needed. In a briefing on Nov. 17, he listed long underwater operations, extended activity without resupply and high underwater speed among their features. He also identified drawbacks: lower underwater quietness than conventional submarines, a larger hull, high costs and the need for specialist skills to operate and maintain the reactor.
Saito also described possible effects on crews' daily lives. More available air, water and electricity could mean more frequent showers and laundry facilities. Conventional submarines' diesel engines can create noise and oil smells, he said, and staff may need to monitor machinery in loud conditions. Those practical improvements would have to be weighed alongside the demands of handling a reactor.
Japan already operates advanced conventional submarines, including boats that use large batteries and air independent propulsion systems. A former senior maritime force officer argued that improving battery technology could allow conventional boats to stay submerged longer without taking on the cost and complexity of nuclear propulsion. The comparison is central to the debate: the question is not simply whether reactor powered submarines can do more, but whether Japan needs those added abilities enough to replace or supplement capabilities it already has.
How large could the bill become?
Construction costs could reach about 1 trillion yen, or roughly $6.3 billion, for each submarine. One estimate that includes construction and maintenance also puts the cost at around 1 trillion yen per vessel. Because a submarine needs major servicing and cannot remain deployed continuously, keeping one in an operating area at all times could require a fleet of about three boats. That would put the potential commitment on a scale of several trillion yen, before counting all the people, bases and support systems required.
A Brookings assessment says construction alone could cost 10 times as much as Japan's most advanced conventional submarines. Those funds would compete with other defense needs, including unmanned aircraft and other unmanned systems, air defense and the supplies needed to sustain forces in a long conflict.
Taro Honda, the Liberal Democratic Party's national defense division chair, questioned whether the project fits the immediate timetable for improving defense capabilities. He argued that training, research and investment would make it difficult to bring the capability into service within five years, and said money and staff might be better used on unmanned systems.
Seiji Maehara, security policy chief for the Japan Innovation Party, takes a different view. He has argued that deciding now is necessary to make a future fleet possible, even if it would not be operational for many years. Maehara said in an interview that use would come no earlier than 2040, because Japan would need to choose a home port, train crews and work with countries that already operate the vessels.
The coalition agrees on missiles, not on the engine
The two governing parties have found common ground on a submarine equipped with a vertical launch system for missiles, but they differ over what should power it. The LDP's proposal referred to using "next generation propulsion," leaving open whether that means nuclear power or improved batteries. The Japan Innovation Party has pressed more directly for consideration of reactor powered submarines.
Honda says the LDP is cautious because of concerns about nuclear proliferation and a regional arms race, as well as the need to compare costs and other defense priorities. He does not reject the submarine idea for the long term. Maehara argues that delaying a decision could prevent Japan from developing the capability at all. Their disagreement is partly about timing: whether resources should first address near term gaps or start work now on a system that might take well over a decade to field.
There are also questions about industrial capacity and staffing. A Japanese naval officer interviewed in the debate said the country lacked the necessary reactor specialists. Another argued that spending 1 trillion yen on a submarine could instead buy a large number of unmanned aircraft and keep personnel out of some dangerous missions. Japan has advanced shipbuilding and engineering industries, but operating a naval reactor requires specialised training, maintenance and safety arrangements.
What does the plan mean for Japan's nuclear principles?
Japan's Three Non-Nuclear Principles say the country will not possess, produce or permit the introduction of nuclear weapons. A submarine powered by a reactor does not automatically carry nuclear weapons, and the submarine discussion concerns propulsion and military capability. The separate draft proposal would keep the principles while expressly allowing nuclear weapons to be brought into Japan in an emergency.
That possible exception concerns the third principle, which bars bringing nuclear weapons into the country. It could affect arrangements for visits by nuclear armed vessels from the United States, although the final wording and circumstances covered have not been settled. Japan's Atomic Energy Basic Act, which limits nuclear power to peaceful purposes, is also part of the legal debate. Critics question whether a military reactor fits that rule and whether a missile equipped submarine would sit comfortably with Japan's exclusively defense oriented policy.
The government has not published a final decision on either question. Ruling party meetings and the expert panel's report are expected before the Cabinet settles the revised documents by the end of December. Any emergency exception would concern the entry of weapons belonging to another country, rather than Japan acquiring nuclear weapons of its own.
Public opposition adds pressure to the discussion
Civic groups have challenged the submarine proposal and the possible change to the non introduction rule. Organizers, including the Citizens' Nuclear Information Center, gathered signatures online over about a month. One account described 47,000 signatures delivered to the Defense Ministry on Nov. 21; another put the Nov. 20 submission at about 46,000. Organizers said acquiring the submarines would betray Japan's stated responsibility to promote nuclear disarmament.
Hajime Matsukubo, co representative of the Citizens' Nuclear Information Center, urged the government to hear the public and warned against a major shift in nuclear policy without national debate. Groups also said the submarine plan and an emergency exception to the non introduction principle could change how Japan is regarded as a state without nuclear weapons.
A Yomiuri Shimbun poll cited at Saito's briefing found 52 percent opposed owning reactor powered submarines and 37 percent in favour. Saito declined to comment on the poll, saying the navy should explain defense preparations carefully and that no decision had been made about a new submarine propulsion system.
How does the argument look beyond Tokyo?
Lyle Goldstein, director of Brown University's China Initiative and the Asia Program at Defense Priorities, has argued that the plan could raise tensions with China and redirect resources from defensive forces. He also points to the shallow waters along much of East Asia's coast, which he says are less suitable for larger nuclear submarines. His view contrasts with supporters' focus on patrols across the wide Pacific and the ability to pursue ships and submarines over long distances.
Japan's possible cooperation with existing submarine programs, including the United States, Australia and the United Kingdom's AUKUS partnership, has also entered the discussion. Any such cooperation would involve political choices as well as engineering. The submarines could give Japan a longer reach at sea, while their size, missile capacity and cost could change how neighbours interpret its maritime posture.
For Japan, the immediate decision is narrower than buying a fleet: whether to put a formal study into motion and specify how quickly officials must reach a conclusion. The process will test whether the coalition can agree on propulsion, how the government handles the separate nuclear weapons exception, and whether the public sees the spending and risks as justified.
Key Points
- The draft security documents call for a review of submarines powered by nuclear reactors and an early decision, not an immediate purchase.
- Research could begin in the early years of fiscal 2027 to 2031, with final documents expected by Cabinet decision before the end of December.
- Supporters cite long underwater endurance, speed and missile launch options; critics cite cost, staffing, legal concerns and alternative defense needs.
- One submarine could cost about 1 trillion yen, and roughly three could be needed for continuous deployment.
- A separate draft proposal would allow nuclear weapons into Japan in an emergency, despite retaining the Three Non-Nuclear Principles.
- Civic groups submitted a petition with about 46,000 to 47,000 signatures opposing the submarines, while a poll cited by the navy chief found 52 percent opposed and 37 percent in favour.






