Ridon Says Duterte Property Testimony Leaves SALN Questions Unresolved

9 Min Read
Ridon Says Duterte Property Testimony Leaves SALN Questions Unresolved

Two properties remain at the center of disclosure dispute

MANILA, Philippines, November 18, 2026. A 379 square meter property in Davao City and a parcel on Samal Island remain disputed in Vice President Sara Duterte's impeachment trial after two city assessors testified for the defense. House prosecutor Rep. Terry Ridon said their testimony left unresolved differences in locations, prices and supporting documents.

Contents
  1. Two properties remain at the center of disclosure dispute
  2. What the SALN dispute means
  3. Samal assessor acknowledges uncertainty
  4. Escudero clarifies the title number issue
  5. Davao testimony turns to photographs and prices
  6. The larger financial allegations
  7. Investment payments and purchases enter the hearings
  8. Cale88 witnesses scheduled for November 19 and 20
  9. Will Duterte testify personally?
  10. Key Points

The defense maintains that both properties, registered under Duterte's husband, lawyer Manases Carpio, were included in her statements of assets, liabilities and net worth, or SALNs. Prosecutors question whether the assets in the property records are the same ones listed in those declarations.

The Davao documents contain figures of P6 million and P10 million. For the Samal property, prosecutors identified different barangay names, acquisition years and purchase amounts. The Samal assessor relied on matching assessed and market values, but acknowledged uncertainty when asked whether the records identified the same parcel.

Ridon said the Senate impeachment court would ultimately decide whether the testimony and documents sufficiently connected the properties to Duterte's declarations. The dispute forms part of Article II, the sole remaining impeachment charge, involving allegations of unexplained wealth and incomplete asset and business disclosures.

The property hearings also feed into a broader financial case. Prosecution forensic accounting expert Alexander Cabrera estimated at least P817.87 million in allegedly unexplained wealth and undeclared assets from 2022 to 2025. The defense has been presenting witnesses on property records, compensation, investments and purchases as it responds to the prosecution's case.

What the SALN dispute means

A SALN is a public official's declaration of assets, debts and net worth. Net worth is the value of assets after debts are subtracted. In this case, the court is examining whether Duterte's declarations accurately and completely reflected properties and financial interests involving her and Carpio.

The immediate property question is about identification. The defense says entries in the SALNs correspond to the parcels identified by prosecutors. The prosecution says differences across the documents leave that connection uncertain.

Advertisement

Property documents can contain several kinds of values. Acquisition cost describes the amount paid to obtain an asset. Market value is an estimate of its worth, while assessed value is a figure used in calculating property taxes. Comparing the same kind of value across records helps explain where a disagreement lies.

For Samal, the defense relied on matching market and assessed values. Prosecutors focused on the address, purchase date and acquisition cost. Those competing approaches explain why the witnesses' confirmation of some figures did not settle the disagreement between the two sides.

Samal assessor acknowledges uncertainty

Island Garden City of Samal Assessor John Kenneth Enumerables testified on November 10 about a property whose title placed it in Barangay San Isidro, Kaputian. Duterte's SALN instead listed Barangay Matanos, Kaputian. Enumerables acknowledged that no Barangay Matanos existed in the city.

The assessor cited an assessed value of P346,960 and a market value of P4,956,600 as his basis for connecting the property records with the SALN entry. Under questioning, he said he had no other basis for identifying them as the same parcel.

Prosecution counsel Benjamin Tolosa Jr. asked Enumerables whether the titled property was the one declared in Duterte's joint SALN. Enumerables, the city's assessor, answered:

I'm not certain, Sir.

Former representative Ace Barbers, a House prosecution adviser and spokesperson, also pointed to a difference in acquisition dates: 2013 in the SALN and 2018 in the deed of absolute sale. He cited an acquisition cost of P4.041 million in the SALN against P3.453 million in the deed, a difference of P588,000.

The defense's position is that the Samal entry and the parcel identified by prosecutors refer to one property. Prosecutors argue that the conflicting details support their allegation that the titled property was left undeclared.

Escudero clarifies the title number issue

Enumerables acknowledged that the SALN did not include a title number or assessment record number that could directly connect its entry to the property documents. He also confirmed that the title contained no annotation of a contract to sell, a recorded reference to such an agreement.

Advertisement

Presiding officer Francis Escudero asked whether the assessor had any basis beyond the matching values for his identification. After Enumerables said he had none and referred to the missing title number, Escudero noted that SALNs do not require a title number.

The court therefore heard two relevant points: the form did not require that identifier, and the assessor's identification rested on the values he compared. Ridon's criticism centered on whether the evidence, taken together, sufficiently established which property Duterte had declared.

Davao testimony turns to photographs and prices

Davao City Assessor Jaime Adalin testified on November 9 about a property in Barangay 74-A covered by a transfer certificate of title ending in 0775. He initially identified the 379 square meter parcel registered to Carpio as the residential lot in Duterte's 2024 SALN.

The price figures became one point of dispute. Prosecutors cited P6 million in the property records, while the deed of sale carried a P10 million selling price. The SALN entry discussed during the hearing also listed P10 million. The difference between the two amounts is P4 million.

Photographs introduced another question. When shown images of a commercial building, Adalin expressed uncertainty about identifying the property. He later explained that a photograph without business signage matched an image in his office's records, but he could not confirm whether photographs showing the restaurant Prime Bistro depicted that same property.

Senator Francis Pangilinan, sitting as an impeachment judge, challenged Adalin over changes in his answers. Senator Bam Aquino also questioned the scope of the assessor's checks.

Adalin said he had not checked all properties belonging to Duterte in Barangay 74-A because the subpoena specified only the title ending in 0775. He was unsure how many properties she owned there and said his office could provide an official record if the court required one.

The larger financial allegations

Cabrera's P817.87 million estimate covers questioned cash balances, properties, income and corporate interests from 2022 to 2025. Prosecutors say Duterte's SALNs from 2019 to 2025 listed no cash on hand or bank deposits despite bank records showing substantial amounts in accounts linked to her and Carpio.

Advertisement

The prosecution has also cited approximately P4.4 billion in transactions involving the couple from 2007 to 2025, drawing on records presented from the Anti-Money Laundering Council. That figure describes transaction activity across a longer period; Cabrera's P817.87 million calculation concerns allegedly unexplained wealth and undeclared assets during 2022 to 2025.

Barbers said the questioned transactions and assets could potentially reach P1.5 billion, while describing Cabrera's figure as a minimum estimate. The amounts remain prosecution allegations before the impeachment court.

Manila Rep. Joel Chua said the defense witnesses had not disputed the prosecution's financial findings. House lead prosecutor and Batangas Rep. Gerville Luistro likewise criticized the substance of the first week of defense testimony. Both were presenting the prosecution's assessment of the evidence.

Investment payments and purchases enter the hearings

GenCorp Industries Inc. corporate counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay testified that Duterte received approximately P2.14 million from the company between 2022 and 2025. She described the payments as returns from an earlier investment but could not produce a written agreement establishing that investment.

Davao City accountant Vingelin Bajan testified about Duterte's compensation during her service in local government. Two other witnesses discussed a P205,007 restaurant bill in Japan and a P256,882 Nike shoe purchase in Malaysia, both paid by Carpio.

The purchases total P461,889, or about 0.056 percent of Cabrera's P817.87 million estimate. Prosecutors said those credit card transactions were outside Cabrera's computation, directing attention back to the cash, assets, income and business interests included in his findings.

The defense also dropped 16 bank officials from its witness list, while constitutional law expert Ralph Sarmiento withdrew as a defense witness. Prosecutors criticized the removal of the bank officials because it ended the prospect of questioning them as defense witnesses about the financial records.

Cale88 witnesses scheduled for November 19 and 20

The impeachment court issued subpoenas for four more defense witnesses scheduled to appear on November 19 and 20. Three are expected to address matters involving Cale88 Foods Corp., in which Carpio held a 47.5 percent stake. Financial records cited by prosecutors showed at least P319 million in inward remittances from China.

Advertisement

The scheduled witnesses have distinct subjects to address:

  • Rainer Dela Fuente of AML Consulting PH is expected to explain concepts under the Anti-Money Laundering Act and identify relevant documents.
  • Trade Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo is expected to discuss Cale88's registration with the Board of Investments.
  • Food and Drug Administration official Pilar Marilyn Pagayunan is expected to address registration of Cale88's sweetened banana chips.
  • Rowena Mendoza of the Center for International Expositions and Missions, or another agency representative, is expected to discuss communications with Cale88, including food exhibition invitations.

Prosecutors want an explanation of the company's financial transactions and their connection to the couple's declared assets and income. The hearings are scheduled to resume after a break for the ASEAN Summit.

Will Duterte testify personally?

Tolosa, the House prosecution's legal spokesperson, urged Duterte to testify personally because she signed and filed the SALNs. As of November 18, her camp had not confirmed whether she would take the witness stand.

The defense had indicated that eight to 10 witnesses remained and expressed hope of completing its presentation by the end of November or early December. The main developments and upcoming dates are:

  • November 9: Adalin testified about the Davao property and faced questions about photographs and the scope of his records check.
  • November 10: Enumerables testified about the Samal parcel and acknowledged uncertainty about its connection to the SALN entry.
  • November 9 to 12: Six defense witnesses addressed properties, compensation, investment payments and purchases.
  • November 19 and 20: Four subpoenaed witnesses are scheduled to testify on anti money laundering concepts and Cale88 matters.
  • End of November or early December: The defense hopes to finish presenting its evidence.

For Ridon, the assessors left the central identification questions unresolved. The defense continues to maintain that the properties were declared. The Senate impeachment court must assess those competing positions alongside the wider financial evidence.

Key Points

  • Ridon said two defense assessors failed to resolve questions about Duterte's property declarations.
  • The Samal records contain differences in location, acquisition year and purchase cost; its assessor relied on matching property values.
  • Escudero noted that SALNs do not require a title number.
  • The Davao testimony involved P6 million and P10 million figures, photographs and a records check limited to one title.
  • Prosecutors allege at least P817.87 million in unexplained wealth and undeclared assets from 2022 to 2025.
  • Four more defense witnesses are scheduled for November 19 and 20; Duterte's personal testimony remained unconfirmed as of November 18.
Share This Article

You May also Like