Big Projects, Failing Everyday Services
Bengaluru needed another 500 million litres of water a day last summer, a shortage equal to one fifth of its demand, according to Karnataka's chief minister. In Mumbai, residents protested against potholes while clogged sewage lines pushed garbage onto flooded roads. Delhi endured another winter of toxic smog, with doctors advising some residents to leave.
Contents
- Big Projects, Failing Everyday Services
- Why City Governments Have So Little Power
- Bengaluru's Growth Outruns Its Water and Roads
- Mumbai, Delhi and Jaipur Show Different Strains
- Heat Is Becoming an Economic Emergency
- Wealth Cannot Buy a Better Public Realm
- What the Smart Cities Mission Has Delivered
- Who Benefits From Smart Development?
- The Urban Expansion Beyond Major Metros
- Water, Sewage and Transport Fail Together
- Six Reasons Repairs Keep Falling Short
- What Practical Reform Would Require
- How the Crisis Has Accumulated
- The Bottom Line
These failures sit alongside hundreds of billions spent on airports, national highways with multiple lanes and metro networks. India has built conspicuous new infrastructure, yet its major cities remain near the bottom of global livability indexes. Traffic, polluted air and uncleared rubbish continue to shape daily life.
As of December 30, 2025, the central problem is how to turn investment into dependable services. A new transport line or digital control centre can serve a useful purpose, while the surrounding city still struggles to maintain drains, deliver drinking water or collect waste. Those tasks require money, staff and public authorities with the power to act together.
India's cities also carry much of its economic ambition. Urban areas already contribute 63 percent of national GDP, with their share projected to reach 75 percent by 2030. More than 600 million people are expected to live in urban areas by then. The places driving growth are simultaneously becoming harder to live and work in.
The pressures connect: weak municipal government slows maintenance; poor maintenance worsens flooding and congestion; heat and pollution damage health and reduce working time. Expensive infrastructure alone has not resolved that chain of failures.
Why City Governments Have So Little Power
India's original constitutional structure divided power principally between central and state governments, without anticipating cities large enough to require substantially stronger governance of their own. Ramanath Jha, a Distinguished Fellow at the Observer Research Foundation, describes an urban governance model that remains fragmented and ineffective compared with other countries.
Ankur Bisen, author of Wasted, a book about the history of India's sanitation problems, describes the imbalance between municipal responsibilities and authority:
Mayors and local councils that run Indian cities are the weakest organs of the state, closest to the citizenry, but tasked with the toughest problems to solve,
The 74th constitutional amendment in 1992 granted constitutional status to urban local bodies and sought to decentralize city government. Its purpose was to let cities take greater responsibility for their own development. Many provisions, however, have never been fully implemented. Bureaucrats and higher levels of government have resisted transferring power, while state chief ministers frequently act as super mayors.
China offers a contrasting allocation of authority. Its city mayors exercise substantial executive control over planning, infrastructure and investment approvals. National mandates operate within a highly centralized system, but local governments have freedom over implementation and face rewards or penalties tied to performance.
Mayors of major Chinese cities also have powerful patrons in the Communist Party's top committee, and their positions can lead to further promotion. In India, many citizens cannot name their city's mayor. The practical issue is who can make decisions, command resources and answer for services when something goes wrong.
Bengaluru's Growth Outruns Its Water and Roads
Bengaluru grew from 790,308 residents in 1951, fewer than 1 million, to 12.76 million in 2021. Its current population is estimated at 14 million. The city known as India's Silicon Valley, home to IT companies and startup headquarters, has experienced rising population density and building density alongside worsening livability.
The expansion has increased demand for water while contributing to higher temperatures. The Karnataka State Natural Disaster Monitoring Centre recorded temperatures above 40 degrees Celsius in 2024, reaching 41.8 degrees on April 30.
Karnataka's chief minister put last summer's daily drinking water shortage at 500 million litres, or 20 percent of demand. That proportion implies daily demand of about 2.5 billion litres. Some residents must buy expensive tanker water. Greater groundwater extraction lowers water levels and eventually dries wells, making a growing population still harder to supply.
Tom Tom's Traffic Congestion Index 2023 ranked Bengaluru as India's most congested city and the sixth most congested worldwide. A journey of 10 kilometres took 28 minutes and 30 seconds, with an average speed of 18 kilometres per hour. Travel time was one minute longer than in 2022.
Bengaluru's frustrations have become public. Residents and billionaire entrepreneurs have voiced anger about traffic snarls and garbage piles. The city's commercial success has attracted people and businesses, but roads, water systems and municipal services have struggled to accommodate them.
Mumbai, Delhi and Jaipur Show Different Strains
Mumbai's pothole protests reflect anger over a basic responsibility: keeping streets usable. During the extended monsoon, blocked sewage lines deposited garbage on flooded roads. The financial capital's ambition in the 1990s to become another Shanghai has run into prohibitive land prices, inadequate affordable housing, overwhelming population density and declining quality of life.
Jaipur's deterioration is visible in its historic fabric. Architecture surviving for centuries is defaced by tobacco stains and competes for space with car mechanic workshops. The damage accompanies a sense of resignation about urban conditions.
Delhi's recurring winter smog leaves children and older people struggling to breathe. Even footballer Lionel Messi's visit was overshadowed by fans chanting against the capital's poor air quality. Pollution losses in Delhi are estimated at as much as 6 percent of GDP.
Across major Indian cities, air pollution is estimated to cause around 7 percent of deaths. Urban flooding carries an estimated annual economic cost of approximately $4 billion. Congestion, illness transmitted through polluted water and air, and unhealthy air itself add lost working hours to the direct damage.
Heat Is Becoming an Economic Emergency
Ten of India's 15 hottest years on record occurred within the last decade and a half. In 2024, New Delhi experienced daytime temperatures above 40 degrees Celsius for an entire month. Humidity can make the air feel as much as 10 degrees hotter.
Extreme heat can overwhelm railways and electricity grids, interrupt exports and leave factories idle. It also harms workers directly. Almost three quarters of India's workforce works outdoors or in indoor settings with little or no cooling, and many workers have informal employment.
Heat stress occurs when the body struggles to cope with heat. A worker who collapses from heatstroke or dehydration may lose the income needed for daily survival as well as the ability to keep working. The International Labour Organization estimates that, by the end of the decade, India's annual productivity losses from heat stress will equal the work of 34 million people employed full time.
Kamlesh Kumar, director of the heat response department at Anugrah Narayan Magadh Medical College, explains the medical danger:
There's not one system in the body that heat spares,
Kumar describes how widely the damage can spread:
Right from the central nervous system to our heart, to our muscles, kidneys and liver, everything is at risk.
Fast growing provincial cities are especially vulnerable where dusty streets have almost no green space. Children and older people struggle first, followed by otherwise healthy adults. In Bihar, a heat wave killed at least 215 people in 2019. During the 2024 national election, 10 poll workers died of apparent heatstroke within 24 hours.
Heat deaths are likely substantially undercounted because high temperatures worsen existing illnesses, which may then be recorded as the cause of death. The health burden reaches beyond the people whose deaths are explicitly attributed to heat.
Wealth Cannot Buy a Better Public Realm
Millionaire migration has become another sign of dissatisfaction. In 2023, 283,000 Indians with net worth above $3 million left the country. A further projection puts departures by 2028 at 430,000 individuals holding total wealth of more than $40 billion. A survey by Kotak Private and Ernst & Young estimated that 22 percent of India's super rich were considering leaving.
Several factors influence migration, with poor urban living conditions prominent among them. Better roads, shorter commutes, cleaner air, cleaner surroundings, dependable municipal services and greater safety make living abroad attractive.
Mumbai, Delhi, Kolkata, Bengaluru, Chennai, Hyderabad, Pune, Ahmedabad, Surat, Vishakhapatnam, Jaipur and Lucknow house most of India's super rich and contribute much of national GDP. They are also among its costliest cities, but living costs are not the principal issue described in these departures.
Wealthy residents can improve conditions inside private homes. Once outside, they share potholed and uneven roads, dirty surroundings, lengthy commutes and polluted air with everyone else. The quality of public space and public services therefore matters even to people able to purchase many private comforts.
What the Smart Cities Mission Has Delivered
India launched the Smart Cities Mission in 2015. By July 2025, 7,636 projects had been completed, with investment stated as $1.53 lakh crore. Eighteen cities had completed all their smart city projects, out of 100 participating cities.
Pune, Surat, Vadodara, Coimbatore and Udaipur have introduced measures including smart traffic management, waste management using connected sensors, integrated command and control centres, smart mobility, digital government platforms and smart water management.
Connected sensors, often described as the Internet of Things, allow equipment to send information about services such as waste collection. Command and control centres bring information together so authorities can monitor conditions and coordinate responses. These tools can support service delivery, but they need functioning municipal operations behind them.
The mission covers approximately 30 percent of India's urban population. The remaining 70 percent lives in towns and cities outside the programme. Its geographical reach therefore leaves most urban residents dependent on other approaches to infrastructure and services.
The financing combines central government money, contributions from states and municipalities, partnerships with private companies and commercial loans. State and municipal contributions are often inadequate, partnerships can be complex, and loans create debt burdens for financially weak municipalities. This fragmented structure has contributed to delays and unfinished projects.
Completed systems also require continuing expenditure on maintenance, upgrades, staff training and operations. Maintenance remains underfunded. Paying to install a system and paying to keep it working are separate demands on municipal budgets.
Who Benefits From Smart Development?
Approximately 25 percent of urban residents live below the poverty line, and 17 percent of urban households live in slums. Their immediate needs include sanitation, safe drinking water, basic healthcare and affordable housing.
The Smart Cities Mission has faced criticism for concentrating on advanced surveillance, premium public spaces aimed at middle class users, commercial districts and technology parks. Critics argue that rising property values can displace communities with low incomes while their basic service needs remain unresolved.
This process, commonly called gentrification, occurs when redevelopment makes an area more expensive and existing residents struggle to remain. A more attractive public space can coexist with greater housing insecurity for the people who previously lived nearby.
India's housing challenge includes nearly 65 million people living in slums, while another estimate places the slum population at approximately 120 million. Conditions include severe overcrowding and missing access to clean water, sanitation or healthcare. Slum density can reach 40 or more people per thousand square metres, compared with recommendations of 8 to 10.
The figures describe a housing crisis especially acute for groups with low incomes. Investment judged mainly by completed technology projects can leave the everyday needs of these residents outside the central measure of success.
The Urban Expansion Beyond Major Metros
More than 600 million Indians are expected to live in urban areas by 2030. A UN projection puts the population at 951 million by 2050; another estimate puts the 2050 total at 814 million. The larger projection describes the largest urbanization wave in human history.
The shift requires 144 million new homes, thousands of kilometres of roads, expanded water systems and infrastructure to dispose of waste. Current infrastructure investment averages only half the amount required.
More than 70 percent of India's urban population lives in settlements with fewer than 1 million inhabitants. Much of the country's urban development therefore takes place outside its best known metropolitan centres.
Cities with populations between 100,000 and 500,000 are growing rapidly but frequently lack adequate planning frameworks, money for infrastructure and technical expertise in municipal administration. Their smaller size does not spare them the need to plan roads, drainage, water supply and housing together.
The economic stakes are substantial. Urban areas' projected GDP share rises from 63 percent to 75 percent by 2030, an increase of 12 percentage points. Infrastructure shortcomings in smaller cities therefore affect a growing part of the country's economic base, alongside the difficulties of its largest metros.
Water, Sewage and Transport Fail Together
Water scarcity affects nearly 40 percent of India's urban population. Chennai has experienced severe shortages that forced residents to depend on expensive private tankers. Supply problems also involve distribution, water quality and inefficient use.
Many cities lose 30 to 50 percent of their water through leaking pipes and poor infrastructure. Approximately half of urban India lacks reliable water supply throughout the day. Groundwater depletion is severe in many metropolitan areas, and microbial contamination remains common in piped water.
Approximately 40 percent of urban households lack proper sewer connections. Septage management, the collection and treatment of waste from systems such as septic tanks, is virtually nonexistent in most cities. Untreated sewage contaminates groundwater and surface water, further weakening already strained supplies.
Transport inefficiency adds a separate economic burden. Congestion costs India an estimated $22 billion annually in lost productivity, while cities lose between 4 and 8 percent of productivity each year to transport inefficiency. Lost time and wasted fuel cost urban economies billions of rupees.
Poor public transport pushes residents toward private vehicles, adding traffic and pollution. Daily commutes exceed 90 minutes in many metropolitan areas. Roads, water and sanitation may be administered separately, but their failures meet in the same neighbourhoods and affect the same households.
Six Reasons Repairs Keep Falling Short
Researchers identify six recurring causes behind the persistence of urban failures. The first is disregard for natural water flows, evident in Chennai, Bengaluru, Gurugram and Mumbai. The second is the lack of dedicated, integrated plans for roads and drainage, which are often treated as separate concerns.
The third is weak municipal financial and technical capacity. Across major states, vacancies average 37 percent, with some cases of a single engineer serving several towns. The fourth is the number of agencies sharing responsibility: Delhi has nine agencies handling roads and drainage, without unified accountability.
The fifth is inadequate planning across wider city regions. Drainage systems and traffic need to connect beyond individual municipal boundaries. The sixth is limited citizen participation, which has slowed corrective and preventive measures at community level.
India also faces a serious information gap. Its last census, described as having taken place more than 15 years ago, recorded an urban population share of 30 percent. Informal assessments suggest nearly half the country has now acquired an urban character, with the next census delayed until 2026.
Bisen links the lack of reliable information to the difficulty of planning:
How do you even begin to solve a problem if you don't have data on the extent and nature of urbanisation?
The gap leaves governments trying to estimate the scale and nature of demand while cities continue to expand. It also accompanies the incomplete implementation of the 74th amendment, weakening grassroots democracy and local responsibility.
What Practical Reform Would Require
Proposals for more resilient cities begin with integrated plans for roads and related services at both municipal and regional levels. Innovative traffic management can reduce congestion, while conserving water bodies and completing rainwater harvesting measures within set deadlines can strengthen water security.
Other proposals include reclaiming low lying waste dumps to create water bodies and developing water ring roads to restrict runoff arriving from outside. Early warning systems using integrated command and control centres would help authorities respond to hazards.
Routine maintenance of roads and stormwater drains, regular safety checks and structural audits would address infrastructure after construction. Filling staff vacancies, reducing excessive dependence on outsourcing and making training routine would strengthen the capacity to carry out that work.
Residents also have responsibilities in protecting footpaths, conserving water bodies, following rainwater harvesting rules and maintaining drainage systems. Citizen participation is part of prevention, rather than simply a response after flooding or service breakdowns.
Financial proposals include fairer, more efficient property taxes, better designed service fees and municipal bonds. A municipal bond allows a city to borrow from investors for infrastructure and repay them over time. Partnerships with private companies can bring resources and operating skills while retaining public oversight and accountability.
Some experts propose private cities operating under specific laws and principles focused on quality of life. These would remain within the Indian Constitution but use municipal laws different from those elsewhere, operating more like businesses with powers to determine functions, raise revenue and decide expenditure.
The common requirement is a closer connection between responsibility, authority and funding. Municipalities dependent on state grants and limited local revenue struggle to sustain services even after new infrastructure is built.
How the Crisis Has Accumulated
India's urban difficulties have developed across decades, with recent heat, water and traffic pressures adding urgency to longstanding governance problems. Several dates show how institutional promises and population growth have advanced alongside deteriorating conditions:
- 1951: Bengaluru's population stood at 790,308.
- 1992: The 74th constitutional amendment granted constitutional status to urban local bodies.
- 2015: India launched the Smart Cities Mission.
- 2019: A heat wave killed at least 215 people in Bihar.
- 2021: Bengaluru's population reached 12.76 million.
- 2023: Bengaluru ranked sixth worldwide for congestion, while 283,000 Indians worth more than $3 million left the country.
- April 30, 2024: Bengaluru recorded 41.8 degrees Celsius.
- July 2025: The Smart Cities Mission had completed 7,636 projects.
- 2026: The delayed next census is expected.
- 2030: Urban population is projected to exceed 600 million, with urban areas contributing 75 percent of GDP.
Bisen points to London's Great Stink of 1858, which prompted construction of a new sewerage system and marked the end of significant cholera outbreaks. He describes how a public health crisis can force neglected services onto the political agenda:
It's usually [during] events like these when things reach a boiling point, that issues gain political currency,
Experts find the absence of an urban outcry comparable to earlier protests against corruption striking. Bisen's example suggests a cycle in which worsening conditions eventually create political demand for action. Bengaluru's public anger, Mumbai's pothole protests and Delhi's smog complaints indicate mounting frustration.
India has vision, scale and capacity for innovation, but remains only partly prepared for its urban future and seriously underprepared in execution. Coordinated planning, inclusion and sustained attention to maintenance remain missing. Cities must become livable, equitable and resilient for infrastructure investment to support the country's demographic and economic ambitions.
The Bottom Line
- Large investments in airports, highways and metros coexist with unreliable municipal services.
- The 74th constitutional amendment granted cities constitutional status in 1992, but many provisions remain incompletely implemented.
- Bengaluru's estimated population of 14 million strains water supplies, roads and public services.
- The Smart Cities Mission covers 100 cities and approximately 30 percent of urban residents.
- Urban infrastructure investment averages half the estimated requirement.
- Heat stress could reduce productivity by the equivalent of 34 million full time jobs by the end of the decade.
- Congestion costs an estimated $22 billion annually, while urban flooding costs approximately $4 billion.
- More than 600 million urban residents are projected by 2030; estimates for 2050 include 814 million and 951 million.
- Stronger municipal powers, staffing, finance, maintenance and regional coordination are central to the proposed reforms.






