Kazakhstan business ombudsman urges digital controls as inspection burden rises with company size

8 Min Read
Kazakhstan business ombudsman urges digital controls as inspection burden rises with company size

Medium businesses face more than 150 times the inspection rate

Kazakhstan's business ombudsman, Kanat Nurov, has asked Prime Minister Olzhas Bektenov to replace mass inspections at business premises with digital controls based on risk, citing a sharp gap in how often companies of different sizes face checks.

Contents
  1. Medium businesses face more than 150 times the inspection rate
  2. What the inspection numbers mean for businesses
  3. A reform launched in law, but incomplete in practice
  4. Only about 23% of the intended areas have automation
  5. Missing business counts leave the 5% limit hard to assess
  6. Unscheduled checks dominate, while more find no violations
  7. Large businesses bear 63% of administrative fines
  8. A common method, public criteria and a possible new administrator
  9. Key Points

Figures in his letter show that in 2025 there was roughly one inspection for every 64 small businesses, compared with 2.5 inspections per medium business and 4.8 per large business. Moving from the small to the medium category therefore brings an increase of more than 150 times in the average inspection rate, Nurov said, creating an obstacle to business growth.

The proposed solution is an automated risk management system, known by its Russian abbreviation SUR, that would use government data to identify businesses needing scrutiny. The aim is to direct inspectors toward risks rather than make company size the main driver of attention.

The Ministry of National Economy's figures for 2026 show how far implementation still has to go: automated solutions cover only 15 of the 66 areas of state control designated for automation. Nurov is seeking government instructions to complete the reform. His proposals have been submitted to the prime minister; no decision or implementation deadline has been announced.

What the inspection numbers mean for businesses

The figures cited by Nurov put the different inspection rates in concrete terms. Small businesses received 37,000 inspections in 2025, against a population of 2.36 million businesses. Medium businesses received 8,000 inspections across about 3,200 businesses. Large businesses received 5,700 inspections across about 1,200 privately owned legal entities.

Small businesses therefore received the largest number of inspections in total, but those checks were spread across a much larger population. Medium and large businesses faced repeated checks on average. For a company preparing to expand, the jump between categories means a potentially much heavier administrative burden.

Advertisement

Nurov, Kazakhstan's commissioner for the protection of entrepreneurs' rights, said the purpose of his proposal was to balance supervision rather than redirect inspections toward smaller firms. He wrote:

This is not about shifting inspections from large businesses to small and medium businesses. A balance is needed.

His approach would retain government oversight while changing how businesses are selected for it. Digital records would help determine where a visit is warranted, instead of relying on large numbers of visits to discover where problems might exist.

A reform launched in law, but incomplete in practice

Kazakhstan's move toward regulation based on risk began with a presidential instruction in September 2020. A law introducing a new regulatory policy for entrepreneurial activity followed in December 2021, as part of a reform described as regulation from a clean slate.

The reform rested on a defined principle: state regulation should respond to risks to people's lives and health, the environment, public order and morality. An automated system was meant to turn that principle into practical decisions about which businesses should be inspected.

  • September 2020: The president called for reform of state regulation of business.
  • December 2021: Kazakhstan adopted legislation introducing the new regulatory policy.
  • January 1, 2024: The risk assessment and management information system formally entered operation.
  • 2025: Unscheduled checks accounted for 92% of business inspections.
  • 2026: The Ministry of National Economy recorded automated solutions in 15 of the 66 areas designated for automation.

The Ministry of National Economy commissioned the information system, and the Center for Digital Government Support developed it. Nurov's letter says technical problems and a lack of subsequent support have left it effectively nonfunctional. More than four years after the law's adoption, he argues, a central mechanism of the reform is still not working in full.

Only about 23% of the intended areas have automation

Kazakhstan has 96 areas of state control, of which 66 were designated for automation. The ministry's count of 15 areas with automated solutions means about 23% of that intended coverage has been reached. The remaining 51 areas, about 77%, have no such solutions.

Advertisement

The system is supposed to draw information from government databases, assign businesses to risk categories, and produce inspection lists and schedules. A risk profile is a structured assessment of the likelihood of problems and their possible consequences. In simple terms, it helps authorities decide where an inspector's attention is most needed.

Creating a single digital system would also require common rules for interpreting information. Nurov's proposals therefore address both the technology and the method behind its decisions: what data to use, how to check its quality, and how to turn it into a decision to inspect a business.

Missing business counts leave the 5% limit hard to assess

Kazakhstan's legislation provides a limit where an automated system is absent: inspections and preventive controls involving visits may cover no more than 5% of businesses subject to control. Preventive controls are checks intended to identify and address compliance problems.

Assessing that limit requires a reliable count of the businesses covered in each regulatory area. Nurov says those counts are missing. During testing of an index measuring administrative pressure on business in 2024, government bodies were unable to provide reliable figures broken down by area of control.

The missing denominator matters. Authorities need both the number of businesses visited and the total number subject to that type of supervision to calculate a percentage. Without dependable totals, compliance with the statutory ceiling cannot be objectively assessed.

Unscheduled checks dominate, while more find no violations

The Prosecutor General's Office recorded that 92% of business inspections in 2025 were unscheduled. Its figures also show that the share of inspections finding no violations rose from 37% in 2024 to 43% in 2025, an increase of six percentage points.

That means more than four out of every ten inspections in 2025 ended without a violation being identified. Prosecutors also identified more than 1,500 illegal inspections.

Advertisement

For Nurov, those figures strengthen the case for better selection before an inspection begins. His proposed system would use information already held by the state to build risk profiles and select businesses for checks through a defined, automated process.

The dominance of unscheduled checks also places practical importance on how inspections are initiated. Completing software alone would leave much of the task unfinished unless authorities also use consistent rules, reliable records and a clear process for deciding which businesses require attention.

Large businesses bear 63% of administrative fines

Administrative fines provide another measure of the burden. Of the 96.4 billion tenge in fines recorded for 2025, large businesses accounted for 60.3 billion tenge, or about 63%, according to the figures in Nurov's letter.

The ombudsman also questioned how the Code of Administrative Offences sets penalties. In 302 articles directly concerning businesses, fines are predominantly expressed in monthly calculation indices, a statutory reference unit used to calculate payments and penalties in Kazakhstan.

A typical scale cited in the letter is 50, 100 and 200 monthly calculation indices, depending on the business category. Penalties can therefore rise by two to four times according to company size. Nurov argues that moving into the next category can automatically double a fine, adding another cost to expansion.

Percentage based fines appear in only 23 of the 325 articles examined, roughly 7%. Their rates also vary by business category. The example given for understating taxes uses rates of 20%, 50% and 80%. Nurov considers this a double accounting for business size: the percentage applies to a financial amount, while the rate itself changes with the company's category.

A common method, public criteria and a possible new administrator

Nurov's office wants a single methodology setting out the principles of risk assessment, approved data sources, rules for building risk profiles, standards for information quality and the mechanism for selecting businesses for inspection.

Implementation would proceed in stages, beginning with areas where businesses face the greatest administrative pressure. The proposal also calls for publishing the full list of risk criteria and their weighting factors. A weighting factor determines how much a particular piece of information contributes to the final risk assessment.

Advertisement

Publishing those details would let businesses understand which factors affect their selection for scrutiny. For authorities, a common method would provide a shared basis for decisions across regulatory areas rather than leaving each area to develop its own approach.

Nurov also proposed studying practices in countries belonging to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. Working groups would bring together the Prosecutor General's Office, the Ministry of National Economy, the Atameken National Chamber of Entrepreneurs and experts to develop and discuss the methodology.

Another proposal would place administration of the automated system with the Committee on Legal Statistics and Special Records under the Prosecutor General's Office. This remains a proposed transfer. Nurov asked Bektenov to issue the relevant government instructions if he supports the initiative.

Key Points

  • In 2025, Kazakhstan recorded one inspection per roughly 64 small businesses, compared with 2.5 per medium business and 4.8 per large business.
  • Automated solutions cover 15 of the 66 regulatory areas designated for automation, according to ministry figures for 2026.
  • Missing counts of businesses subject to control prevent an objective assessment of compliance with the 5% inspection limit.
  • Unscheduled checks made up 92% of inspections in 2025; 43% of inspections found no violations.
  • Large businesses accounted for 60.3 billion tenge, or about 63%, of administrative fines.
  • Nurov seeks a common risk methodology, public assessment criteria and phased implementation. Government approval and a timetable have not been announced.
Share This Article

You May also Like