Thai Tax Court Rejects Thaksin Bid to Halt Asset Seizures in 17 Billion Baht Dispute

10 Min Read
Thai Tax Court Rejects Thaksin Bid to Halt Asset Seizures in 17 Billion Baht Dispute

Collection Can Continue While Thaksin Challenges the Tax Claim

Thailand's Central Tax Court on November 16, 2026, rejected former prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra's request to stop the Revenue Department from seizing or freezing assets to collect a tax claim of about 17 billion baht arising from Shin Corporation share transactions.

Contents
  1. Collection Can Continue While Thaksin Challenges the Tax Claim
  2. Why the Court Rejected Temporary Protection
  3. The Enforcement Rules Behind the Decision
  4. The Argument Over More Than 40 Billion Baht
  5. How the Shin Corp Transactions Created the Dispute
  6. Why the Tax Claim Shifted to Thaksin
  7. Seizure, Auction and the Bankruptcy Question
  8. The Dates That Shaped the Case
  9. An Appeal Alongside the Continuing Lawsuit
  10. Key Points

The court ruled in case number ภ 59/2569 that Thaksin could not use Section 254 of the Civil Procedure Code to seek temporary protection against these collection measures. It classified the department's actions as enforcement under Section 12 of the Revenue Code, placing the dispute within a different set of legal procedures.

Thaksin had also sought to stop announcements of public auctions of seized assets. His lawyer, Winyat Chatmontri, said an auction had not yet taken place and that the legal team would appeal the dismissal.

The underlying lawsuit against the Revenue Department continues. The court has scheduled a hearing for December 21 to identify the disputed facts and legal questions that the parties must address. Winyat said arguments about the assessment and assets taken previously would be examined when evidence is heard.

The dispute follows a Supreme Court ruling on November 17, 2025, ordering collection of a tax assessment of 17.629 billion baht. Thaksin's immediate challenge is therefore about how collection proceeds while he pursues his objections in court.

Why the Court Rejected Temporary Protection

Section 254 allows a plaintiff, the person bringing a lawsuit, to request certain protective orders before judgment. Such orders can prevent harm during a case, including situations where another party might move or dispose of assets needed to satisfy a later judgment.

The court explained that these protections belong to the part of the Civil Procedure Code dealing with temporary measures before judgment. Section 264, which also concerns protecting a party's interests during proceedings or securing compliance with a judgment, sits within that framework.

Advertisement

Thaksin's position was different, the court reasoned. The Revenue Department was already exercising statutory powers to recover tax that its director general considered overdue. For that purpose, the department occupied a position comparable to a creditor enforcing payment, while Thaksin occupied a position comparable to a debtor.

A creditor is a person or organisation seeking money owed; a debtor is the person required to pay it. Although Thaksin brought the current lawsuit, the court examined his role in the collection process when deciding which procedural rules applied.

The court dismissed the application under Section 254(2), read together with Section 17 of the Act Establishing Tax Courts and Tax Case Procedure of 1985. Its reasoning places challenges to the collection process within enforcement procedures, rather than the temporary protection procedure Thaksin had used.

The Enforcement Rules Behind the Decision

Section 12 of the Revenue Code was central to the court's reasoning. It provides the authority under which the Revenue Department was proceeding against Thaksin's assets to recover unpaid tax.

The court referred specifically to the fourth paragraph of that section. It directs that seizure and public auction procedures follow the Civil Procedure Code with the necessary adaptations. Attachment procedures, which can freeze money or other property, follow regulations set by the director general with ministerial approval.

The court interpreted that reference to the Civil Procedure Code as pointing to its enforcement provisions. Those provisions govern the taking and sale of a debtor's property to pay a creditor.

Section 289 was also discussed. The court explained that a debtor or another affected person who challenges a creditor's right to enforce, or the legality of enforcement, may seek a suspension when the conditions in that section are met. Any further application would need to satisfy the relevant legal requirements.

The Argument Over More Than 40 Billion Baht

Winyat said Thaksin's central factual objection concerns more than 40 billion baht in assets seized or frozen in 2010. The legal team argues that those assets relate to the same pool of money now being pursued through tax collection.

Advertisement

Thaksin's lawyers describe the current collection effort as unlawful duplication. The Revenue Department's position, reflected in the court's explanation of its enforcement powers, is that it is recovering tax assessed as due and unpaid.

The figures describe different parts of the dispute. The assessment ordered collected by the Supreme Court was 17.629 billion baht. The amount exceeding 40 billion baht is Winyat's description of assets taken or frozen in the earlier proceedings. The court will examine the claimed connection between them during the continuing case.

The earlier amount cited by the lawyer is more than twice the 17.629 billion baht assessment. That comparison explains why his team is placing the history of the assets at the centre of its argument: it wants the court to examine what was taken, which funds were involved and how that affects the current collection claim.

How the Shin Corp Transactions Created the Dispute

The tax case grew out of share transfers involving Ample Rich Investment Ltd., a company registered in the British Virgin Islands in 1999, and Thaksin's children, Panthongtae and Pintongta Shinawatra.

Ample Rich sold each sibling 164.6 million Shin Corp shares at one baht per share outside the stock exchange. On January 23, 2006, the siblings sold the shares through the Stock Exchange of Thailand to companies affiliated with Singapore's Temasek Holdings, at a market price of 49.25 baht per share.

The difference between the acquisition price and the market price was 48.25 baht per share. The Revenue Department treated the benefit from acquiring the shares at one baht as assessable income for the 2006 tax year. Assessable income is income that must be considered when calculating tax liability.

The department initially pursued the children. On August 30, 2007, it assessed tax and surcharges of 5.90479 billion baht against Panthongtae and 5.67686 billion baht against Pintongta, a combined 11.58165 billion baht. They challenged the assessments through administrative appeals and then in the Central Tax Court.

Ownership became decisive. The Supreme Court's Criminal Division for Holders of Political Positions found that Thaksin remained the true owner of 1,419,490,150 Shin Corp shares and that the children held shares on his behalf. The siblings relied on that finding to argue that they were not the people liable for the tax. On December 29, 2010, the Central Tax Court annulled their assessments.

Advertisement

Why the Tax Claim Shifted to Thaksin

The Revenue Department revisited collection during the government of General Prayut Chan-o-cha. Officials met on March 13, 2017, as a March 31 deadline approached, seeking a legal route to recover the tax before the limitation period expired.

The approach used Sections 820 and 821 of the Civil and Commercial Code, concerning responsibility between a principal and an agent. In simple terms, officials sought to hold the person behind the transactions responsible for actions carried out through others.

On March 28, 2017, the department issued Thaksin a personal income tax assessment for the 2006 tax year totalling 17.629 billion baht. The notice was delivered to his registered home address shortly before the deadline.

Thaksin challenged the assessment and initially won. On July 18, 2022, the Central Tax Court annulled it because the department had failed to issue him a summons under Section 19 of the Revenue Code before making the assessment. The Specialised Appeals Court's Tax Division upheld that ruling on June 2, 2023.

The Supreme Court reversed those decisions on November 17, 2025, and ordered collection. It found that Thaksin had concealed ownership through his children and that the arrangement lacked economic substance, meaning it did not reflect a genuine change in the underlying economic ownership. The court also found improper purposes, including tax benefits, and gave no grounds to waive or reduce surcharges.

Seizure, Auction and the Bankruptcy Question

Winyat said the Revenue Department had already seized or attached some assets. Seizure places property under legal control for collection, while attachment can prevent money or property from being transferred or paid away.

A public auction is a later step: property is sold and the proceeds become available to meet the debt. Winyat said that stage had not yet occurred. The November 16 dismissal leaves Thaksin without the temporary halt he requested as those collection procedures continue.

Advertisement

Bankruptcy also arose in the lawyer's comments. Winyat said any attempt to pursue bankruptcy would have to be examined against the applicable legal criteria, including questions surrounding the amount recovered from assets.

No auction date or bankruptcy decision was announced. The immediate proceedings concern collection measures, the proposed appeal against the temporary protection ruling and the continuing tax lawsuit.

The Dates That Shaped the Case

The dispute has moved from share transactions to assessments against the children, then to an assessment against Thaksin and the current enforcement challenge. The main dates show how those stages connect.

  • January 23, 2006: Panthongtae and Pintongta sold Shin Corp shares to companies affiliated with Temasek through the Stock Exchange of Thailand.
  • August 30, 2007: The Revenue Department assessed a combined 11.58165 billion baht in tax and surcharges against the siblings.
  • December 29, 2010: The Central Tax Court annulled the siblings' assessments after they challenged their status as the taxpayers.
  • March 28, 2017: The department issued Thaksin a tax assessment totalling 17.629 billion baht.
  • July 18, 2022, and June 2, 2023: The tax court and appeals court ruled in Thaksin's favour over the summons procedure.
  • November 17, 2025: The Supreme Court reversed those rulings and ordered collection.
  • November 16, 2026: The Central Tax Court dismissed Thaksin's request for temporary protection against collection measures.
  • December 21, 2026: The court is scheduled to identify the issues for the continuing lawsuit.

The December hearing will help define which facts each side must establish and which legal questions the court must resolve. Winyat referred to evidence being heard in 2027, without specifying a date.

An Appeal Alongside the Continuing Lawsuit

Winyat said he had informed Thaksin of the dismissal and that the former prime minister had instructed the team to continue through the legal process. The lawyer confirmed the next step in a brief statement:

We will appeal this order.

The legal team plans to challenge the procedural ruling while continuing to argue the facts of the tax dispute. Those tasks concern different questions: which procedure can be used to seek a halt to enforcement, and how the assessment and earlier asset seizures should be treated.

For Thaksin, the concrete consequence is continued exposure to asset collection while those arguments proceed. For the Revenue Department, the requested suspension has been refused, leaving its collection powers in place subject to the continuing legal process.

Advertisement

Key Points

  • The Central Tax Court rejected Thaksin's request to halt seizures, attachments and auction measures on November 16, 2026.
  • The court ruled that the collection process falls under enforcement rules rather than temporary protection under Section 254.
  • The Supreme Court ordered collection of a 17.629 billion baht assessment in November 2025.
  • Thaksin's lawyer says assets exceeding 40 billion baht taken or frozen in 2010 are central to the continuing challenge.
  • Winyat plans an appeal and says no public auction has yet taken place.
  • The next scheduled hearing is December 21, 2026, to define the disputed issues.
Share This Article

You May also Like